And Yet Another All Time Heavyweight List - HA!

I see a guy in your top ten who only managed three successful title defenses, one highly disputed with no rematch given, and went 0-3 in fights with guys in the top ten that went 12 rounds.

I see a 20+ defense champion who is absent not only from the top ten, but from the list.

 

I think you should revise it again

 

Corbett over Klitschko?

 

No Klitschko in that list, that's crazy.

 

All due respect. Liston, Holmes, Tyson, Frazier, Patterson to low. Johnson, Jeffries, to high. Shavers shouldn't be on here when Wlad isn't. You're still one of my favorite posters mate.

 

Did Shavers even had some belt?
I think he didn't had beated nor Ali nor Holmes and from 70 ies most notable boxers are Holmes, Frazier, Foreman and Ali while Norton too looks more notable than Shavers cos he once had beat this Ali and had strange decision loss vs Ali.

 

1-Muhammad Ali.
2-Joe Louis.
3- I don't want to get overpowered by anyone here, H2H he wouldn't make it in the top 20, but in term of accomplishments, i think he deserves this spot. So The number 3 should be :Rocky Marciano.
4-Lennox Lewis
5-Sonny Liston
6-George Foreman
7-Larry Holmes
8-Evander Holyfield
9-Mike Tyson
10-Joe Frazier
11-Riddick Bowe
12-Vitali Klitschko.
13-Jack Dempsey.
14-Wladimir Klitschko
15-Floyd Patterson

 

I love Commander Vander as much as the next guy or more but how is he no 3?

 

Mike Tyson is so overrated because people love his horrible and vulgar personality and I assume boxing style.

Best wins: Spinks (not even a heavyweight and was petrified and retired immediately after), the ghost of Holmes, Bruno, Tucker, Berbick....

Such a poor list. Got beat black and blue by Holyfield, Lewis, Douglas, Williams and McBride...

 

What accomplishments are you referring to exactly?

 

The only heavyweight champion to retire undefeated.
The Only heavyweight to make every single defense against the top contender.
Beat Ezzard Charles, Joe Louis, Jersey Joe Walcott, Archie Moore ex....all of them were past it, but it wasn't Rocky's fault.

 

Holyfield at 3? Tainted by steroids.

Dempesy? Who did he beat to be that high? Wills is arguably higher.

Frazier, winner of the FOTC, at 19?

Archie Moore as a heavy?

Ernie Shavers? Did you intend to write that?

No Wlad Klitschko? Really?

You got 1 and 2 right, and the rest are fairly subjective. I don't agree completely, but don't have a problem with them, either.

 

I'm no wlad fan but he belongs on the list no doubt a top 15 hw at the least.