I dont see how you can say his resume has surpassed fedor when 90% of the guys on his ufc resume are mid level guys, its all about context at the time fedor smashing nog is miles ahead of anything silva has done, imo he would have to dominate jones to get a win as big as that.
You produce some good points as to why it is so close for myself and why I only just favor Anderson. You left out the bad ones. BTW I have no idea why you think I am talking about "looks" and "super hero physique" when I state I consider athletic ablity. :huh Manny was a bad example as well - that's a "super ped" physique according to a lot of haters (and Mayweather).