Very difficult one. Toney has wins over Holyfield and John Ruiz, but has also been extremely inconsistent. Ruiz Jr has always been talented but just hasn’t ever looked at Toney’s level. If this is prime for prime then Toney wins it. However who knows in what condition either of these turn up in. Both prefer eating to training.
Good fight, Toney is the better fighter overall, but in the heavyweight division Ruiz would have a better chance I think...