Anthony Joshua a top 10 puncher

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Glass City Cobra, Mar 10, 2024.


  1. lordlosh

    lordlosh Boxing Junkie banned Full Member

    7,759
    7,482
    Jun 4, 2014
    Based on what exactly is Wilder harder puncher than AJ? Knocking 30+ complete glass jaw bums ?
    When did Wilder KO a legitimacy iron chinned fighter?
    Hell Wilder couldn't even drop f**** Johann Duhaupas even once. I'm yet to hear a guy Wilder manage to KO and has a solid solid chin.

    Also there is different kind of powers and how what they did to you when you get hit.
     
    Last edited: Mar 10, 2024
    MaccaveliMacc likes this.
  2. Glass City Cobra

    Glass City Cobra H2H Burger King

    10,306
    17,659
    Jan 6, 2017
    Well Wilder sparked Brezeale and Helenius out in 1 round and it took Joshua 7 rounds for both. People who sparred with both guys have consistently rated Wilder higher in multiple interviews on YouTube (I think Dubois is one of them).

    In terms of stopping durable opponents, Wilder stopped Arreola with a broken hand when Vitali couldn't as a side note. He is still the only man to KO Ortiz, something Thompson, Martin, and Ruiz couldn't do. Nobody made Stiverne look as bad as Wilder did in their hilariously 1-sided rematch (even when washed up nobody has made Stiverne look that bad, not even a prime Joe Joyce).

    Wilder has more early KOs and more KOs in General. He also passes the eye test. The only advantage Joshua has in his favor is KOing more ranked contenders.

    To answer question in regards to how to measure power objectively even with a shortage of elite opponents, I use these criteria:

    -Visible effects: Very straightforward. What sort of impact do the punches have on opponents? Do they regularly rattle and wobble people? Do they score plenty of knockdowns? Do opponents become cautious and tentative when hit, or do they just fight right back...?

    -Size of opponents: It's impressive when you can KO big men who are 220+ regardless of their skill level. If the majority of KOs are against much smaller men, it's usually less impressive.

    -Chin of opponents: Again, very impressive to stop a very rugged durable opponent whether they're ranked or not. A solid chin is a solid chin.

    -Age and condition: The closer the opponent is to their prime, the better. Also, if they have any prior/current injuries they're recovering from it can put a big asterisk* on the KO.

    -Quotes: People who fought/sparred giving testimony of how hard they hit can be interesting, but this is supplementary and not primary evidence.

    -Different styles/skill levels: KOing a wide variety of styles (swarmers, movers, counter punchers, boxer punchers, sluggers, etc) is a VERY good indicator someone has legit world class power--not to mention skill and the ability to make adjustments.



    If a power puncher can get high marks in most or all these categories, KOing several elite opponents is just the cherry on top (although that is still arguably the most important category). Someone like Ernie Shavers or Tommy Morrison for example both score high in all of these but lack in wins over ranked opponents. Yet nobody with a pair of functioning eyes would say they weren't elite punchers.
     
  3. lordlosh

    lordlosh Boxing Junkie banned Full Member

    7,759
    7,482
    Jun 4, 2014
    Internet is such a weird place where everyone suddenly decides to talk about anything, without even have a clue what the heck he is talking.

    Buddy AJ is probably the fastest HW currently. Maybe Usyk is faster, but Usyk is pushing 37, so maybe it's not anymore. Ruiz is essentially retired and i doubt that his speed is what it is.
    Saying AJ lacks speed is like saying Mike Tyson was lacking KO Power or speed. Also AJ is all about fast twitch muscle. You have no f**** clue what you are talking. AJ is probably the most explosive fighter since Tyson as well.
    Also AJ stamina is great. He outthrow Usyk by 112 punches in their first bout, and Usyk has the best cardio in the HW division by far.
    Also people have no idea what stamina is, and how it's even work. It's one thing throwing arm punches, and what it's drain from your gas tank, and completely different throwing hard full force punches, that firstly drains a lot more stamina, and you drain your overall gas tank a lot faster like that, as your recovery is different throwing full force punches.

    Go on to the bag and throw 10 regular solid punches, and then do the same with full force everything behind the punches, which is what AJ mostly do, and see the difference.

    AJ had improve his stamina tremendously since he comes out as a pro, and he now knows how to pace himself a lot better.
     
  4. lordlosh

    lordlosh Boxing Junkie banned Full Member

    7,759
    7,482
    Jun 4, 2014
    I'm not reading all of that, but just the beginning.

    Firstly Wilder hasn't beating a single good name. Secondly Ortiz chin is close to pure china. He was floored multiple time by not so solid shots. His chin is anything but good.

    Secondly, if we going by your logic:
    AJ KO Molina in 3, and Wilder went life and death with him and needed 9 rounds.
    Helenius KO may have something to do with that he was WIlder sparring partner, and that he was id**** open and on the front foot against Wilder, compare to running scared on the back foot against AJ, and all defensive.
    Still Helenius was out COLD both times.

    But going your logic:
    Wilder never managed to hurt ot drop the only real good chin he has ever faced - Johann Duhaupas.
    Povetkin brutally KO him in 6.
    Wilder needed 9 round to KO a glass jaw bum in Szpilka, which Chisora KO in 2. And Kownacki KO him in 4.

    Does that mean Chisora and Kownacki > Wilder in terms of power?

    Wilder never KOed Arreola it was corner stoppage.
    Stiverne KO Arreola in 6.

    And the rest of Wilder opponents are complete glass jawed bums, that don't even have wikis ....

    Things don't work like that in Boxing.
    Ah and what happen when Wilder face someone with a good chin again ? Aha Parker, and he couldn't do a s**** on him.
     
    MaccaveliMacc likes this.
  5. chacal

    chacal F*** the new normal Full Member

    14,731
    12,169
    Jun 21, 2015
  6. Glass City Cobra

    Glass City Cobra H2H Burger King

    10,306
    17,659
    Jan 6, 2017
    I mean AJ's punches lack speed compared to other elite ATG punchers such as Tyson, Joe Louis, Frazier, Dempsey, Ruddock, or even Wladmir. Do you dispute this?

    As for his own era, yes Usyk is faster, so is Ruiz, Parker, and Wilder. That's 4 people off the top of my head. That doesn't mean I think Joshua is "slow". There's levels to speed. Joshua is absolutely not more explosive than Wilder and if you think that you're the one who has no idea what you're talking about.

    AJ's stamina is good...for a super heavyweight. But not "great". Great stamina would be guys like Ruiz, Vitali, etc who can punch hard all night over a dozen punches over round. Other examples in previous eras would be Tua, Mercer, Frazier, etc. In terms of punching cardio, Joshua had good stamina but not great.

    I do that in the heavybag all the time. Last year I was throwing full force punches for 10 rounds straight. Yes Joshua has gotten better and that's a positive mark for him. I wasn't saying he had "bad" stamina, but not quite as high as other elite HWs hitters.
     
  7. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,152
    20,798
    Sep 15, 2009
    I think his powers definitely top ten in the division today.

    There's only really Wilder, Zhang and Joyce I think who have an argument for being considered on his level.

    So for me he's top 5, not just top ten.
     
  8. Glass City Cobra

    Glass City Cobra H2H Burger King

    10,306
    17,659
    Jan 6, 2017
    That's fine. I wasn't talking to you anyway.

    China chins do not have only 2 KO losses in 30+ fights in the HW division, both to the same guy. Especially when they're well into their 40's.

    I don't see how any of this remotely debunks my suggestion Wilder hits harder than AJ.

    Wilder can both be an extremely hard puncher and a sloppy puncher with poor technique/finishing skills.

    One of the most durable guys Tyson faced was Holyfield who was stopped by James Toney. Does this mean Toney hit harder than Tyson...? How about Frazier finishing Ron Stander when Shavers couldn't, does Frazier hit harder than Shavers? I happen to know the context for all those fights and I know the answer is an emphatic "no" to both questions unless you're clueless.

    Do you think more power=automatically should KO someone based on common opponents who have less power...?

    See if you had read my post or bothered to ask you wouldn't be asking these stupid questions.

    You're complaining about some opponents lacking wikis...? Do you actually watch fights, or do you just look at stats and then mouth off like a keyboard expert?

    I literally went in depth explaining all the various factors that go into what makes someone a good puncher and how KOs can happen. I don't only use ABC logic based on common opponents. Since you seem to be very rude and confrontational, I'll let you read the rest of my post so you can get a better understanding of how things work since you seem to be confused. If you don't want to, that's your issue.
     
    Kiwi Casual likes this.
  9. Glass City Cobra

    Glass City Cobra H2H Burger King

    10,306
    17,659
    Jan 6, 2017
    Top 5 is very charitable of you given the division's very extensive history of big hitters.

    Who do you rate as being the top 5?
     
  10. catchwtboxing

    catchwtboxing Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    26,420
    34,817
    Jul 4, 2014
    I make the case that he is clearly better than Wilder.

    1) Wilder's power is mostly against bums and medically unfit fighters. He put down Fury a few times, but Fury has been put down by a cruiser, a novice, and a featherfist that no one remembers, so it's not all that great an accomplishment.

    2) Wilder's power is only from a highly telegraphed straight right hand. Joshua's is more two-fisted and at different depths.
     
  11. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,152
    20,798
    Sep 15, 2009
    The top 4 are Wilder, Zhang, Joyce, AJ. Unsure on order. After that I reckon Hrgovic but his power isn't proven at the top level like the others.

    But that's my top 5.
     
    humbug likes this.
  12. Glass City Cobra

    Glass City Cobra H2H Burger King

    10,306
    17,659
    Jan 6, 2017
    Oh, I thought you meant top 5 of all time across the entire history of HW boxing.

    That's fine I guess, although I think AJ's power is more proven and effective than Joyce who seems to mostly just be a clubber (a good one, mind you).
     
  13. CooperKupp

    CooperKupp “B.. but they all playin NBA basketball again!” Full Member

    2,029
    4,203
    Aug 28, 2022
    Good list. :thumbsup: I personally would swap out Lyle for The Duke as far as raw power.
     
    KINGWILDER likes this.
  14. KINGWILDER

    KINGWILDER Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,789
    2,597
    May 11, 2023
    Very fair, Morrison deserves to have his name on any top heavyweight punchers list.
     
    CooperKupp likes this.
  15. lordlosh

    lordlosh Boxing Junkie banned Full Member

    7,759
    7,482
    Jun 4, 2014
    AJ obviously ain't as fastest HW in terms of all time, but for today era, he is one of the fastest one for sure.
    It's his main asset, as well as power, explosiveness, etc.

    Wilder ain't as fast and that is for sure. Wilder couldn't lay a glove on a version on Parker that to me is inferior to the one AJ fought. Parker that fought AJ was insanely fast, and even he admitted that he lost some of that speed, due to bulking like a *****.
    Ruiz for sure was faster than AJ. We don't know is he faster now with his inactivity and his lifestyle.

    Usyk has always been faster, but we don't know for sure if it's now, as he is 37 years old.

    As far as the explosiveness goes, AJ is more explosive than Wilder, and it's not even close.
    You can prove me wrong with a single clip like this one:
    This content is protected


    The only one in the close past i'm thinking which is more explosive is prolly Mike Tyson. Same for putting string/combos together.

    As far as stamina goes, Vitali, Usyk, etc have not great, but literally ATG cardio. AJ is not there, never was, never will be, mainly because of his build, and that he is so explosive. That and the muscle he have require a lot of stamina out of him. He may have great gas tank, but it depletes quicker because of his build.

    He is like a sprinter. 0-100 in record time, but can't keep it for long, simply because he is so explosive and so muscular.

    Vitali Klitschko for example, has a lot better build for boxing in my book, literally perfect body, and it's essentially naturally for him.
    AJ is a trained machine, and train very hard to keep it. But Vitali also ain't hit as hard as AJ in terms of one punch power. He is an accumulation puncher.

    My example with the try it on the heavybag is for anyone literally. Hell even as shadow boxing. Because there is a huge difference to your system if you put everything into your punches even for short period of time, and just throw regular punches, but not put everything on them.
    I can throw literally around 100 regular punches, and not get tired, but the moment i start putting everything and i mean everything into my punch, firstly i get tired very quickly, which is obviously normal, and then don't have the same energy after it. I mean it's take a lot more out of your body. Your recovery is completely different.