Vargas by decision 80% Vargas by TKO 10% Margarito TKO 5% Margarito Decision 3% Draw/DQ/Robbey/FanMan 2%
Vargas was too skilled of a boxer and punched with too much power for Margarito ( who wouldn't have a size advantage). Technically it would be a mismatch, and Vargas would no slouch inside.
Difficuilt to judge what type of animal Margo is @154 , can he be the bullying walk forward force he is @147 ??? against a prime Vargas id suggest not !!!!! Vargas by 4 rounds !!!!!! UD .............
Vargas would dominate the first 5 or 6 rounds but eventually Margarito starts doing damage as Vargas gets Ballsy and starts brawling with Margo, it would be a foty type. Margo comes on late and does more damage in the later rounds but too late!! Vargas by close decision.
Definitely Vargas, probably by stoppage. Vargas was a much better boxer than Margarito has ever been, not to mention he's bigger and stronger. I really can't think of a justifiable reason for picking Tony.