Who wins this gem? Against common opponents old man Archie did pretty well, even later than this date Archie ruined rated new hope aljando laverante. Chuvalo peaked about the Jones and Patterson fights much later on. I think in 1959 I old man Moore has the edge.
Archie wins it in a one sided cake walk - he wouldn't be silly in there either because as limited as Chuvalo may or may not have been he was solid as a rock - that being said I think he'd get his head boxed off