Are Khans Wins over Judah and Malignaggi underrated now

Malignaggi, probably.

Judah, not really.

Malignaggi performance I have always loved, I actually think that is his best performance of his career (along with Kotelnik). Great display of the offensive jab and handspeed.

Like I said with Judah, not really. Judah will continue to look great against (I don't like labelling boxers as the following) but C/B- level boxers, but up against world class, young, fresh, hungry boxers...he will continue to fold mentally.

 

No offence but the guy paulie beat ****ing sucked big time, first time I watched him and couldn't believe he was a world champion. That being said paulie was the underdog and good luck to him.

Khan is much better than Paulie and always will be.

I want to see Paulie v Judah at 147.

 

Amir Khan

proving that

Terroist Middle Eastern Slick >then black and italian slick

what else you wanna know?

 

This content is protected

 

This.

Khan vs Malignaggi was one Amir's best performances.

Amir has quite a good resume for a boxer his age. Kotelnik, Malignaggi, Maidana, Judah and arguably Peterson.

 

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shUqYIkMXu0[/ame]

This

 

I want to see Malignaggi prove a little more at welterweight before I say he is great at 147

 

Paulie was flat at 140, lost his legs. He hadn't had them since a while before he fought Hatton. Even when he beat Diaz, he used his sholder to force Diaz back and create punching room, rather than use his feet to manouver around him.

147 seems to of given him a spring back which is vital when you consider his unorthodox defense. Now I think Khan beats Paulie no matter what weight, because he's faster and longer, but I don't think Khan beat the best of PM that night, I really don't.

 

Anyone that calls Khan a hypejob dksab

 

No.

 

Judah is just so on and off it hard to gauge much from it, he's not in form for periods of time, more just single fights.

I also agree that Malignaggi just seemed pretty burnt out by the time he fought Khan, he was coming off a busy 2 years and was having troubles with the weight. It's hard to raise a fighters victory with another fight when it was in a completely different weight class.

 

Not really, to be honest. Paulie didn't exactly beat someone special. He STOPPED the guy, for crying out loud. Do you know how **** of a world champion you have to be for Paulie Malignaggi to **** up your face and stop you?

Khan's win over Paulie was always pretty decent. Especially the manner in which he did it. What Paulie's done afterwards doesn't really enhance it that much, in my opinion. Because the moment he steps back in with a Khan level opponent (say, Alexander), he'll probably get beaten again. He hasn't really gone on to prove to be better than what what he was against Khan.

 

Malignaggi didn't do anything so special. It was clear the Ukrainian was not the right champion.
Malignaggi is still not with the Elite even holding such a title.