Are Pacquiao's accomplishments @ 147 really "that much" better than pbf's?

Of course Floyds welter record is better... He's been there for the better half of the last decade...

 

But as far as quality of opposition goes per fight its about equal...

 

Only one way to settle who's the better welterweight.... And it seems only one man wants to prove who it is...

 

yea Floyd ducked him.

Why did Margarito turn down a fight with him then?

 

Since 2006. PBF fought ONLY 5 times at 147!

2006 Carlos Baldomir - 147lbs
2007 ODLH - 154lbs
2008 Ricky Hatton - 147lbs
2009 JMM - 144lbs - jmm MOVED two divisions higher! Never fought on this weight and only had two fights at 135lbs
fought pac at his best weight at 130lbs but JMM fought FMJ at 144lbs BUT FMJ REFUSED TO
TO HAVE HIS WEIGH IN BEFORE THE FIGHT! Professionalism FMJ standards!
2010 Mosley - 147lbs


NOW LETS DISSECT

2006 Carlos Baldomir OK
2007 ODLH 154LBS
2008 Ricky Hatton 147lbs BUT we ALL KNOW that at 147lbs Hatton
moved 7lbs from his comfort zone
2010 Mosley is PEAK at this stage of his career!

AND FMJ has the GUTS to call himself ATG?!?!!!!! :rofl:rofl

 

Hatton was in 07. And Floyd took a near 2 year break. Between that time.

 

HE TOOK the break?! Cotto, Margarito and Williams were good options but too risky for FMJ so he took the break and made a come back to fight

BLOATED JMM! funniest **** about FMJ fans and FMJ himself is that they claim that they school JMM! THE INTIONALLY FAIL TO REALIZE THAT fighting JMM at his best at 130lbs is TOTALLY different at 144/147lbs :hey

PAC fought Hatton at his BEST fighting weight at 140lbs! While FMJ was again in his comfort zone fighting at 147lbs :deal

 

Floyd has talked about a break before the Baldomir fight.

The JMM fight was nothing more than a warm up. While JMM was P4P 2,no one tries to claim it was one of his greatest wins.

Hatton was an ex champ who vacated his title.

Hatton at 140 was good but who didn't see Pac destroying Hatton beside hardcore Hatton fans?

If I would of known Pac carried his power to 140 I would of said a KO inside 3 but I said TKO 10 with Pac winning all rounds.

 

Mosley => Held WBA title at 147, when Floyd fought him.
Baldomir=> Held WBC, IBA, and Ring titles at 147, when Floyd fought him.
Judah => Held IBF title at 147, when Floyd fought him.

Cotto => Held WBO title at 147, when Manny fought him. But, he fought him for it at 145.

In terms of fighting more decorated opponents at WW...Floyd is the clear winner, at this point. Now, Cotto does hold wins over both Judah and Mosley. So, one could, possibly, argue a Cotto win >= a Mosley win + a Judah win. But, Mosley was higher ranked than Cotto, when Manny fought Cotto, and Floyd fought Mosley. So, in just comparing Cotto and Mosely, Floyd still has the best win, based on the rankings, and the perception of each fighter, at that time. Floyd has the better resume at 147, at this point, IMO.

 

You need to be quarantined.

 

Says the guy who hates Mayweather yet only talks about him.

 

At the end of the day, floyd still ducked him.

 

floyd avoid fighting on that 2 yaer span knowing WW were loaded with live dogs.

Typical of floyd like at present running scared to face Pac.

 

Yes, Floyd ducked Margarito who turned down a fight with him.

 

so basicly facts dont matter u just want to hate?