Are these boxers Hall of Famers? I've chosen specifically those boxers on the borderline. Please judge them as their boxing career stands today. Joel Casamayor Diego Corrales Jose Luis Castillo Israel Vasquez Rafael Marquez Juan Manuel Marquez Joan Guzman Oscar Larios Junior Jones Jermaine Taylor Kelly Pavlik David Tua Chris Byrd Ricardo Mayorga Fernando Vargas Ricky Hatton Miguel Cotto Zab Judah Arturo Gatti Shane Mosely Vernon Forrest Cory Spinks Mikkel Kessler Joe Calzaghe Antonio Tarver Nonito Donaire
Joel Casamayor - YES Diego Corrales - YES Jose Luis Castillo Israel Vasquez Rafael Marquez Juan Manuel Marquez Joan Guzman Oscar Larios Jermaine Taylor Kelly Pavlik David Tua Chris Byrd Ricardo Mayorga Fernando Vargas Ricky Hatton Miguel Cotto - WILL BE IF HE CONTINUES BEATING THE TOP QUALITY FIGHTERS HE HAS RECENTLY BEEN DOING Zab Judah Arturo Gatti Shane Mosely - YES Vernon Forrest Mikkel Kessler Joe Calzaghe - YES Antonio Tarver
I added Junior Jones to the list. Is he HOF? He did beat Barrera twice with KO's, and fought but lost to Erik Morales.
Joel Casamayor Diego Corrales Jose Luis Castillo Israel Vasquez Rafael Marquez Juan Manuel Marquez Joan Guzman Oscar Larios Junior Jones This content is protected Kelly Pavlik David Tua Chris Byrd Ricardo Mayorga Fernando Vargas Ricky Hatton Miguel Cotto This content is protected Arturo Gatti Shane Mosely Vernon Forrest Mikkel Kessler Joe Calzaghe This content is protected This content is protected
I didn't spend much time looking at the list, so I missed Mayorga, and as for Pavlik its just way too early to tell.
I'm glad someone agrees that Mayorga is a HOF. He did after all beat Vernon Forrest twice at his prime (even though the second fight could have gone either way), he lost a controversial fight to Cory Spinks, and beat Fernando Vargas and Michel Piccirillo.
I didn't agree that he was a HOF. I said I missed his name on the list otherwise I would have laughed at him too. He's not anywhere close to HOF status in my book.
