Good fight. It still could & should happen now. I got Chisora on points. At their primes, I got Arreola (who I picked as I suspect you mean both at their best).
I've always favoured Chisora in this match up. I think Chisora's head movement would be the difference and allow him to get the better of the exchanges for the most part. It probably goes the distance both guys can take a punch.
Chisora would stop Arreola in 6. Hrs limited, but offers a toughness that Arreola could not withstand. *fun fight though! I’d tune in
Areola is not in it to win anything, he was happy to just exist in the Ruiz fight. Chisora takes him out.
Both fighters have shown questionable levels of motivation at times. Arreola only seems to be able to get himself up for fighting fellow Mexicans. But not for title shots or eliminators it seems. Chisora is still up for it and has been a good version of himself in recent years. So Chisora with the stoppage in this one
I would take Chisora now or in their primes. He's just the better fighter. He's competed at higher levels.
I might be a little bias but a focused Nightmare who fought Ruiz Would beat chisora. He'd just have to get past the first 4 rounds, if he did i think Arreola can win a decision.