its hard to say,but i would go with paz on points because gatti could be out hustled and paz had a good chin and was just as strong.i would say a split decision for paz in a close war.
I like Gatti at 135; Paz was drained at 135..... In truth, both Gatti and Paz were on fairly equal terms with skills and speed, but I like Paz all the way after his 1991 accident.... The Paz who came back from a broken neck was pumped and ripped and much better at the higher weight than Gatti could ever imagine.... How Paz could weigh a buffed and solid 165 for Duran in 1994 on PPV leads me to believe he was really roided up in the middle 1990s...... I know he was never nailed or caught using, but my suspicion is there..... MR.BILL
All I have to say is that Vinny was a better fighter then Angel Manfredy, and Ivan Robinson. That should answer your question on who wins.