At what point did heavyweight "giants" learn to punch with correct technique?

He didn't say acceleration and shoulder ... you say that's where the force comes from. I'm saying the mass can come from other than the shoulder.

Acceleration is the increased rate of velocity (speed). For the purposes of this discussion, they are close enough. You never mentioned acceleration or speed or any other such factor as having an affect on force, just shoulder and stepping forward. So your physics are incorrect.

You said there's one way to throw each punch and every other way is wrong. I've shown you your own quotes. Do you deny saying that?

Again, just because I've taken your own words and shown that you have changed your argument is no reason to start with insults. I don't think you're an idiot. I think you're wrong. Furthermore, I credit you with enough intelligence to realize that I have shown that you are wrong -- there is more than one way to correctly throw a punch -- but you don't want to admit it so now, again, you resort to name-calling.

The fact is, there is more than one way to correctly throw each punch. You cannot dispute it because I've shown you various ways.

End of discussion.

 

I've asked you a simple question, if you are this expert you seem to believe you are, you should be able to spot the flaw. ps You have already switched the topic .

 

St Pat is truly wise in these ways. When we can snatch the pebble from his hand, then we can go.

 

Oh dear. Saint Pat vs Dago Wop. Even the WBC wouldn't sanction this mismatch. Brain versus prawn.

 

Muscles do generate force. There are muscles other than shoulder muscles.

I've shown you Riddick Bowe and Larry Holmes pushing off the back foot -- leg muscle generating force.

You never once mentioned acceleration or speed or anything like that as a factor in creating force. I brought it up. You said "stepping into the punch and the shoulder" created the force behind the jab. I've shown you other ways that do not involve that.

There is more than one basic technique because there are variations of punches. You say, and I quote you yet again, that there is only one way to throw each punch. I showed you there are many.

 

Kung Fu - The film.

 

This entire discussion has been predicated on the quoted post by YOU in "your thread."

Your topic presumes that there is, as you put it in the quote above, "only one way of throwing each punch." So a discussion of exactly what that "one way" is for each punch is quite on topic.

And large heavyweights have thrown "correct" punches for quite some time. Probably as long as any other size fighter.

 

All punches are correct if they do the job they are intended to do.

 

Liar must be your favourite word,easy to use from the safety and anonymity of your pc.