Benny Leonard (seeded 2) makes a mockery of the notion that boxers from the 1920s were outmoded by evolution in pugilism. He moved like a ballerino, gliding away, floating in, his balance all but absolute. Leonard was not an Ali or a Sugar Ray, his moves were functional as well as effortless and beautiful, but the terrible threat of his punches were the reason for his mobility as he sought the proper position from which to punch. He sought to punch Rocky Kansas from all angles when they met for the fourth and final time in 1922. Kansas hadn’t been stopped for eleven years and a hundred fights, but Leonard left him sagging after a savage assault the likes of which would arguably go unequalled until Ray Robinson hit his stride twenty years later. Leonard was that good; he stands that comparison. Hard to hit and granite of jaw, champion Freddie Welsh seemed impossible to beat in any no-decision bout, as proved to be the case when Welsh got the better of him in 1916 over ten, with the title on the line. No championship for Leonard, though the newspapermen in attendance naming him the better of the two but, unable to score the knockout, the reigning champion left the ring with the title. You can almost see Welsh smirking down the century when, just under a year later, he granted Leonard a rematch, once again over ten rounds. But Leonard was all business. “I am after the knockout,” he said. “I intend to win that title tonight or get well licked trying. This may be the last time I get a crack at Welsh.” Leonard was aggressive, direct, and brilliant. In the ninth, he pinned Welsh to the ropes behind a wall of leather and as the Brit slipped, ducked, rolled, and caught his abuser’s punches on his gloves and arms, Leonard moved his attack downstairs. Welsh fought more than 150 fights and he was only stopped once – May 28th, 1917, in New York, New York when stopping him was the only way Leonard could win the title. That is the difference between the great ones and the true immortals: the immortals find a way. Leonard made himself immortal over the following seven years. No lightweight could beat him. Lew Tendler probably came the closest, pushing him hard in a no-decision bout in 1922, so in 1923 Leonard granted him a decision bout over fifteen, boxed his ears off, sent him scurrying for welterweight. Leonard retired the undefeated lightweight champion of the world. I credit him with seven title defenses (though he is 9-0 in title fights if we allow his Newspaper Decision win over Welsh in their first title fight), ignoring the one he staged against Jimmy Duffy at 140lbs. During this time he was, perhaps, a lightweight unbeatable. This content is protected Sammy Angott’s welterweight career was a disaster. He was battered from pillar to post by fighters like Sugar Ray Robinson, Ike Williams, Henry Armstrong; lesser lights, too, had their way with him. The first two years of his career were no kinder to him. A ledger of 16-10-2 details his shortcomings as a prospect. When he hit his lightweight stride, however, he did damage to the division so severe as to be directly comparable to that wrought by contemporary Lou Ambers. It began for him with a trilogy against the sometime #1 contender Davey Day, who he “whirlwind punched” to a standstill in their first October 1939 contest, earning himself a unanimous decision. Day, who was famous for his slow starts, rallied wonderfully in the final two rounds of their rematch two months later to take a split, Angott perhaps hampered a little by his determination to stay busy, a fact that saw him beat no less a figure than Baby Arizmendi between his first two matches with Day. Whatever the truth of that, he won the rubber staged at the dawn of the 1940s to lift a lightweight strap. By the end of 1941 he was undisputed and lineal having hoovered up the other lightweight belt taking names like Bob Montgomery and Lew Jenkins on the way, although he was beaten by a lightweight Ray Robinson in this period – something in which there is certainly no shame. Matching the bigger Robinson for a second time up at welterweight reeks of kamikaze; a few months after his second loss to Robinson, Angott retired amid the astonishing news that he had been fighting with a bum right hand ever since his 1940 contest with Montgomery. This represents the end of Angott (seeded 15) as a lineal champion, but he did return to the ring and with matching Robinson deemed futile he instead met Willie Pep. Pep, perhaps the greatest featherweight in history, was less lethal at lightweight but still represents a significant scalp; according to one ringside report, Angott won all ten rounds against the legendary Pep, an astonishing performance from the 3-1 underdog who certainly re-earned his nickname, “The Washington Windmill.” Allie Stolz, Slugger White and Bobby Ruffin were additional ranked victims in this second career which was dominated by his welterweight disasters but saw him continue his good work at lightweight. At his best, Angott was brutal. He stayed close to his foe, punching perpetually and although he was too given to holding to ever become wildly popular he was still something of a fan favorite during his title years. Early inconsistencies and his injury-hampered run as king exercise some drag on his placement here, but he was a great lightweight and one who was never stopped at the poundage. This content is protected Who will win under the following rules? 15 round fight. 1930s referee. 8oz boxing gloves. 10 points must. Cast your vote and explain yourself in a post below! You have 3 days.
Leonard is a different class. I don't think anyone has come since Leonard and look superior on film. He really can do it all. I take him to do this on points.
Sammy, coz he's my favourite in this thing and he's obviously not gonna win. Leonard boxes nicely, but no moreso than Willie Pep, Angott's body shots help slow Benny down whilst he keeps on his pressure. Leonard's offence is negated by the infamous clutch, and Angott crowds his way to a very close decision. Classic boxer vs swarmer match up
I think Angott would have some success neutralizing Leonard's offense in close and Leonard would box his way to a close, possibly split decision. Angott gives it his all but comes up just short against the more versatile Leonard.
Benny Leonard bought his way to the second round of the ATG lightweight tournie with a win every bit as convincing as the one that Gans turned in over Kid Lavigne earlier, dropping both the second and third rounds to Sammy Angott's whirlwind attack and another pair late as he twice landed hard right left hands to momentarily trouble Leonard; that aside, it was the Ghetto Wizard front to back as he tattooed Angott late in whats in reality a rather drab affair outside of the four rounds Angott trouble Leonard in. 11-4 x3, UD.