ATG Ranking is based solely on what happens in the ring?

BoxNation All Time Great Poll results:
1. Ali
2. Robinson
3. Mayweather Jr.
4. Leonard
5. Marciano
6. Tyson
7. Louis
8. Jones Jr.
9. Duran
10. Calzaghe

OK, my bad, they didn't rank Lennox in the top 10 ever.

http://www.***********.com/mayweather-ranks-3rd-on-boxnation-all-time-great-poll--69097

 

Well then...

...you'd be wrong.

Fill in the asterisks with that one website that has scene a lot of boxing. Then add the below after the .com/

mayweather-ranks-3rd-on-boxnation-all-time-great-poll--69097

 

It's cool jas...

You don't need to defend the average opinion of a Brit boxing fan anymore, hahaha... they know NOTHING!

I am highly opinionated, as is most everyone, and that's what makes boxing's historical lore so fascinating and debatable because it is so widely up to interpretation.

 

it's about what they did in the ring, and only the ring. though it can be skewed due to the fighters personality outside of the ropes.

Ali being the one who stands out most in this area.

 

that is one horrible top ten. doesn't even bare thinking about.

 

Oh mah gawd... Marciano above Louis as well.. Mind****.

 

This has and always will be the way fighters are judged. No serious argument can be made otherwise.

 

Sugar Ray Robinson beat his wife on a regular basis.

She had 5 miscarriages

 

I agree. Calzaghe too low.

 

Void could not knock out the woman he beat up. ATG is biased and P4P is a bunch of crap..............