ATG: Who Ranks Higher, Canelo or Donaire?

Then you proceed to claim that some of his wins are losses. That's not looking at his record then now is it.

 

Like I said before, with the exception of Mickey Walker, those are middleweights who became light heavyweights. Canelo was a junior middleweight who became a light heavyweight champ.

 

What about the original argument? The one ovids tore down. Do you give it to canelo now?

 

None of those guys were ever A-level fighters.

Consider that A levels are MAB, Morales, JMM, Naseem, Kevin Kelly (barely, maybe an A-), Rigo, Donaire, Inoue, Nelson, Fenech, Loma. Walters is probably B-C, Frampton is a B+ on his best day.

 

So you don't view those guys as A-level fighters. That's fine. As long as there are very few A-level wins across all of current boxers' accolades... In which case his resume still stacks up just as great so doesn't even matter.

 

You're right, there are very few A-level wins. Which is why Canelo only has 1 A-level win, GGG. Unless you're going to argue that Darchinyan is on equal level ability-wise to GGG.

I'm not sure who is greater as of now, I thought it was Donaire, but Canelo has a decent argument.