ATG: Who Ranks Higher, Floyd Mayweather Jr or Erik Morales?

Voted for Floyd but meant to vote Erik.... Floyds resume is good but is highlighted by having no blemishes... Erik should rank higher based on resumes..

 

Morales and it's not even close. Why? Cause Floyd is running scared of EM's left over :deal

 

Mayweather is much better.

 

still floyd no doubt.

 

Money mayweather!

 

Better boxer : floyd
Better resume : Morales

Morales is greater

 

Morales didn't duck the top fighters in his weight class. Floyd ducked Margarito, Cotto, Williams when they were CHAMPIONS of his division.

 

Are you seriously comparing the content of Morales resume to JCC Jr. and Valuev!?!?

What is impressive about the statement of bringing up his undefeated record is that its packed of all the tough fighters in or around his weight class.
Its not a cherry picked resume like PBFs.

 

His resume speaks for itself. Floyds resume is at the same level of Calzaghe's. So where ever people placed Calzaghe is where Floyd should be at. Skill wise Floyd is up there and competes with eveyone else. When placing one in the ATG rankings, resume is a high factor and skills play second. When ranking P4P, skill level is the bigger factor and resume is second. Am i wrong on this?

 

morales

 

Haha so the best fighter he ever fought was a 38 year old Mosley who has shown he is way past it and not to mention more than likely over trained as he was training for a cancelled fight then had to call it off for the PBF fight.

I rest my case!!

 

It has to be Floyd - elite boxer but amatuer human being .

Love Morales though - not the greatest of his era but a legendary warrior with the heart of a lion .

 

Congratulations - you win 1st prize for the most brain farting comment of the day on ESB ( no mean feat )