ATG: Who Ranks Higher, Floyd Mayweather Jr or Erik Morales?

the fact that this is even close proves the ******* population of esb is overwhelming. esb is schocking with Mayweather hate, they're not even in the same league.

 

****ing crazy. I didn't even vote.

 

more like black guy picks black guy in poll cause hes black

 

or that morales is seen as an equally great fighter despite of the loses. that goes to show that those loses doesn't mean much if you continue to challenge yourself and fight the fights that people wants from you.

 

:deal

 

we are comparing what they have accomplished so far right?

pale in comparison just because guys in the lower weight are not well known? pacquiao and barrera alone shits all those in floyd's resume.

thank you for admitting that pacquiao alone is better than any of floyd's wins.

you are talking as if morales' was outclassed by barrera who is also a future HOF and a fellow ATG. giving barrera and pacquiao 6 great fights are part what makes morales' great. he is keen on taking on challenges and this is why people see him as a great fighter and in this case as great as floyd even if he have those loses.

 

This is the dumbest **** I've ever heard. If you don't see the difference then .

 

No, Pacquiao and Barerra are not enough to **** on Floyds resume. The clueless Pacquiao nation claims this because they know Morales's resume is inferior to Floyds after those two names. Morales's losses dont count either huh?

These answers are a bunch of troll answers, so ill ask you this. Who is greater to you, Morales or Floyd?

 

Are you ****ing serious? You cant judge a fighter that way until his career is over orbs fight you think should've happened, didn't happen. You ****ing Pacquiao trolls don't know **** about boxing. You don't even care about what you're saying, that's the sad part. Sad!

 

why would you blame the pacquiao fans for the results of this poll? floyd only has himself to blame for not taking the greater challenge like what morales has done in his career. floyd value's his "0" thinking that this would make him greater than any of the other boxers currently and the past and some of you are falling for it. i didn't say the loses doesn't count, but it doesn't mean much in evaluating a fighters greatness if he was seen as someone who took all the challenges.

meanwhile, as a floyd fan, you are confused why many people thinks morales is as great as mayweather in this poll because you value his zero more than anything.

personally i have floyd ahead but don't be mad when people sees morales as equally as great or even greater than your idol floyd.

 

I can't believe Floyd is up by votes. :-(

While Morales is beating the likes of Pacquiao, Floyd is fighting Bruseles.
While Morales is having an epic battle with Barrera, Floyd is fighting Augustus. :-(

 

Considering their career up to now, their longevity, the quality of their opposition and of course theirs skills, I think they would be pretty much even which is reflected perfectly by the poll result so far. Floyd's skills really helped him on this one. He does have a great resume but I judge fights on what I see and I do think Floyd '0' should have been taken away since Castillo I.
My heart goes to Erik though. If Floyd had a tenth of Erik's courage he would have been among the greatest.

 

Are the polls based on resume and achievements or just resume?

 

You saved yourself personally. Two fighters don't make a resume.

 

What the **** do you know about a fighters courage?