ATG: Who ranks higher? Juan Manuel Marquez or Erik Morales?

A lot of Morales knob gobblers on this site so don't expect a reasonable argument here.

 

If you're not gobbling that knob you're a homo :bart (no homo)

 

Erik Morales 18-8-0 (9) *20-6-0 (9)
Valdez, H Sanchez, Zaragoza, Bueno, Junos, Chacon, Ramirez, McCullough, Barrera (x3), Kelley, Espadas (x2), Chi, Ayala, Croft, Chavez, Hernandez, Pacman (x3), Raheem, Diaz*, Maidana* (21)

Juan Manuel Marquez 16-4-1 (9) *18-3-0 (9)
Gervacio, Sanchez, Cotey, Cabrera, Norwood*, Jimenez, Pedan, Medina, Gainer, Salido, Pacman (x2)*, Polo, John*, MAB, Juarez, Casamayor, Diaz (x2), Mayweather, Katsidis (19.)


here are their notable resume's IMO with potential HOF opponents being highlighted. the second record is with amendments based on fights I've scored different from official results.

 

Morales for me. This decision has nothing do with Jose Sulaiman hand-delivering the WBC lww belt to his front door, but more to do with the fact that the resume he built during his prime years is clearly better than JMM's.

 

close maybe morales
H2H JMM

 

morales better wins, JMM longevity

 

Morales, clearly.

Marquez had done some catching up after his loss to Pac (Diaz, Casamayor), but after he was beaten by Floyd, he went back to his old self fighting fights that nobody cared about.

 

Morales, and not close.