Baffled how on "all" judges scorecards have FMJ winning rounds 3 and 12?

garcia won hitting nothing but air. case closed.

 

Floyd clearly won rounds 1-3 and 11-12.

 

You could argue that Pacquiao only one 2 rounds. Giving him 4 rounds means that you gave him every close round. People say Floyd ran but he landed nearly twice as many punches. Running is when you are retreating without throwing back. Floyd outboxed him clearly. I was extremely shocked to come online and see that anyone would have scored this fight for Pacquiao

 

I initially called the round even, but after re-watching it, I thought Floyd controlled enough of the round and landed enough clean shots to ensure that Pac's later round flourish couldn't over-take it.

After re-watching the fight, I only gave Pac rounds 4, 6, and 10, so 117-111 on my card.

 

I scored it like this-

Round

1. PBF
2. PAC
3. PBF
4. PAC
5. PBF
6. PAC
7. PAC
8. PBF
9. PAC
10 PAC
11 PBF
12 PBF

114-114

 

Me too.

 

A lot of people feel that Pacquiao won the 9th and 12th round as well... with those 2 rounds PAC would be the winner 115-113

 

I don't get how people are saying Pacquiao won either of the rounds mentioned in the OP. :conf (3rd or 12th)

I didn't even feel they qualified as swing rounds, personally.

Weird, though, because there was definitely a round I gave Pacquiao that I noticed some people with obvious anti-Mayweather bias (including Mosley scoring on Twitter) gave to Mayweather. :blood

 

9th was absolutely a Pac round. 3-12 werent Floyd rounds, those could be scored either way. Floyd certainly did not win more than 6 rounds, coupled with his deserved but never given deduction, the fight should have certainly been decided in favor of Pac.

 

I wanted PAC to win but I had Floyd winning with 8 to 3 and 1 draw. I can't recall besides round 4-6 I gave PAC and the 6th cuz Floyd gave to him

 

I don't believe Floyd ran I can say he boxed well with lateral movements cuz he also was in front of PAC and PAC did nothing but be hesitant

 

Pac won 4 and 6 thats it.

 

All my RBR scoring, collated.

Manny's really strong period was from the 4th, when he initially hurt Floyd, until the eighth, where he last had consistent success banging Floyd with the left hand and walking him down. Of those 5 rounds I gave Pacquiao four of them, and the only round I gave to Mayweather (the 5th) was acknowledged to be "very close" - meaning I could easily agree w/ a scorecard having Pacquiao sweeping all five in a row.

The 1st three and last four were very clear, typical Mayweather 10-9 rounds. He made Pacquiao ineffective, aggressor or not, and did enough in each of those (whether just pot shot jabs or walking Pacquiao down with lead rights) to clearly edge them on the criteria upon which boxing is supposed to be scored.