Based Soley On Resume Who Ranks Higher Holyfield Or Corbett?

The Sullivanv Kilrain fight was under London Prize Ring Rules.
How many of Kilrain's fights were under Queensbury rules?
Kilrain's previous 2 fights prior to Corbett were a win over a debutee and a draw with a guy who was 0-1-0.
Of his last 21 fights he had actually won 10 the others were no decisions or draws.
Corbett actually has only 2 wins over good heavyweights Sullivan who hadn't fought in 4.5years and Kilrain.
Mitchell was a middleweight ,McCaffrey a super middle,McCoy a super middle, Choynski then a middleweight. Corbett was ko'd by a middleweight Fitz, and beaten by a light heavy Sharkey.
McCaffrey was beaten by 5'8" middleweight Dempsey who, a year later scaled 151lbs for a fight .

 

The Sullivanv Kilrain fight was under London Prize Ring Rules.How many of Kilrain's fights were under Queensbury rules? Kilrains previous 2 fights prior to Corbett were a win over a debutee and a draw with a guy who was 0-1-0 Of his last 21 fight he had actually won 10 the others were no decisions or draws.Corbett actually has only 2 wins over good heavyweights Sullivan who hadn't fought in 4.5years and Kilrain.
Mitchell was a middleweight ,McCaffrey a super middle,McCoy a super middle, Choynski then a middleweight. Corbett was ko'd by a middleweight Fitz, and beaten by a light heavy Sharkey.
McCaffrey was beaten by 5'8" middleweight Dempsey who a year later scaled 151lbs for a fight .

 

ATG's don't have 23-17-4 records with 13 ko losses. Goddard has a decent chance against Corbett , but that doesn't make him a great fighter.

 

I'm focusing on the fact that 4 of Corbett's most famous wins were over middleweights !
Let me put it another way if I had included Bobby Czyz's 5 round defeat by Holyfield as a significant win for Holyfield you would have been down on me like a ton of bricks yet at 211lbs ,[the same weight as Evander,]Czyz outweighed McCoy,Choynski,McCaffrey,and Mitchell by, in some cases,over 40 pounds!
ps The division was sh*t, Corbett was a big fish in a tiny pond in an era when a 5 fight nobody could be a contender and the standout challenger Jackson could be ignored because of his colour.The very fact that 150lbs Dempsey was being considered as a challenegr for Sullivan speaks volumes for the depth of the division.

 

In repliment to your missive of the information that was provided whereas Nelson was not effective as a boxer because handicap of one eye and one arm so limited was he severely to single punches thrown . It is known well that bar knuckle fighters are irrelevant because they are barred, therefore so you just make more said that are not the truth but tales of fairies. Once again I triumph!

 

If you don't think its warranted look at the post directly below it!