I thought that Amir was very good on the last Primetime show. He arrived at 1am after hosting a major charity event (his charity) and was sharp all night. He can fall into the Audley-easy-soundbite trap but he can also be sharp and honest. Adios.
In all the interviews I've watched with him he just sounds baffled from moment to moment. I'm sure he's a nice kid, but he really should engage his brain before his mouth.