Before claiming someone is a top 10 atg..please show a list to back it up

those stats were great but should be placed in perspective.... extra weightclasses and especially 4 world titles per weight, makes it much easier to become world champion in 8 division now, then it was to be 3 time worldchampion in the 50's...

almost all his world titles are suspect... he has a total of 5!!! Title defenses, he has never had more then 1 title per weight..

his 112, 120 and 130 titles are the only ones that have some meaning... his 147 title is arguable credible... his 135 and 154 don't mean nothing... and where did you get the other 2 titles from?

oh i see.. 126 and 140 as far as i know.. he never won a title at 126, he drew against marquez for the title.. and 140? are we going to count the IBO title too???!!??

 

Obviously, this is pretty much the most subjective and debatable subject in all sports.

People must understand the value that must be placed on fighters from beginning of the sport-1960's, as the sport of boxing was the #1 or #2 sport in the world. Nowadays, it is somewhere between hockey and horse-racing, so I cannot see the possibility of fighters of today stacking up to fighters of yesteryear. The relevance factor just does not stack up.

 

He would also **** Floyd up so whats your point dumbass what the hell does that have to do with the rankings?

Barkley beat Hearns ass twice should he rank higher than the hitman?

 

How come you don't have Jimmy McLarnin on your list? Hasn't he defeated like 12 HOFer's?

 

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Muhammad Ali
4. Harry Greb
5. Sam Langford
6. Manny Pacquiao
7. Joe Louis
8. Ezzard Charles
9. Roberto Duran
10. Willie Pep

11. Benny Leonard
12. Ray Leonard
13. Pernell Whitaker
14. Archie Moore
15. Mickey Walker
16. Bob Fitzsimmons
17. Joe Gans
18. Carlos Monzon
19. Marvin Hagler
20. Barney Ross

21. Gene Tunney
22. Rocky Marciano
23. Barbados Joe Walcott
24. Alexis Arguello
25. Kid Gavilan

 

One thing that helped Pacquiao ge those titles is the fact that he was allowed to start his career at 16 and when he wasn't matured

 

Ok **** head, but did I say Floyd was top 10 all time, no I'm said Thomas Hearns would Ko Pacquiao and he shouldn't be ranked behind him

 

well 8 world championship in 8 different divisions, 1st in the history of boxing.....bring somebody in to match that.

fighter of the decade and fighter of the year for 3 consecutive years (will be).....and tell those 1000 reporters who voted for it to shutup because you dont agree with them. at least they are somebody and youre nobody.

just a suggestion, just shut the **** up!

 

Greb, SRR, Hank, Duran, Langford, Fitsimmons, Charles, Pep,Charles,B Leonard,

Pacman,

No order just at the top of my head, He cannot be to far behind the guys 0n top, don't think he is ahead of any of those guys though

 

nice post caneman..Stats don't lie

 

Pac is ahead of Duran in every stat by Caneman

 

Thats a poor list.