Floyd is a.fuking *******, but he seems to be one of the most talented fighters out there today. His talent to me is not a doubt, but his legacy is. His best win is over castillo, hattpn and mosley and from that bunch castillo is barely considered a great. Oscar was already on his way out. So were mab, morales, cotto, hatton, amd margarito. Its sad but true. jmm is still kicking ass and was never a beaten man or in danger of getting retired by manny because pacman never beat him. The saying they dont makem like they used to firmly applies here. Sergio martinez and paul williams rank higher imo than those 2 charlatans. Manny and floyd are extremely talented and fun to watch vs limited opposition, but unless they fight each other or a martinez or williams they should never be mentioned on the same breath when referring to the fab 4 of the 80s. They have good wins, but not good emough.
Some of you guys are lying about being a Floyd AND Pac fan I have been following Manny since 04 when he beat Barrera. I became a Floyd fan after he retired in 07-08. I used to like them about even until I started watching Floyd more. I am a big time fan of technical boxers so I like Floyd a lot more. When Manny had TKOed Oscar people were saying Manny would beat Floyd but, I didn't see it then and I don't see it now. Don't get me wrong Manny is a great fighter but technical fighters are my favorite :good.
I lean more towards Mayweather, simply because I beleive him to be the better fighter overall. But I enjoy them both for different reasons. And Yes, I think they both ATG greats.:deal