Best acomplished welter in the last 15 yers.

Toss between Tito and Mosley but i give the edge to Tito even though an argument can be made for Mosley and is one of my Fav fighters.

 

Tito

 

I can't believe so many are voting PBF. He heat Baldo and Judah - that's it.

He's not he most accomplished or best in terms of h2h match ups. Not even close.

 

Trinidad

 

I think Felix Trinidad did well.

 

Thats what happens when polls aren't public and you cant see who voted in who.

 

Because there is no Pac as an option

 

To the people that voted Floyd can you explain to me how he is better than Oscar, Tito and Mosley at WW/ Even than Cotto.

For example Cotto at WW Judah by KO
Floyd beat him by UD
Cotto beat Mosley, Quintana and Clottey
Floyd must answer to that with Baldomir
The question is not who could have been the most accomplished but who is

 

1.Mosley
2.Oscar
3.Tito
4.Mayweather
5.Quartey

I won't count Sweet Pea and Buddy McGirt as they were in decline by '94.

Mosley is top coz he beat Oscar fair and square at 147 (Oscar won the rematch but that was at 154), Oscar second because he beat Tito fair and square, Tito third because of his solid resume at the weight, Floyd fourth because of his weaker resume at the weight, and Quartey fifth as he is the best of the rest. Ike would beat Margarito, Cotto or Williams IMO.

 

:admin I've only just noticed the poll score - have so few people actually seen the Trinidad v Oscar fight?! Oscar won easily 8-4. It wasn't even closer. This is like saying Chavez was better than Whitaker over 135.

atsch:nut

 

gotta be Shane, I know I give him a rought time, but he fought 5 of the mentioned and beat 3.

 

I mean people will always try to discredit Floyd by keeping him in the mention of these guys who have each been fighting at WW for a decade. Young Floyd couldn't get the fights with Shane and ODLH and all of these guys, even back then as a lightweight willing to step up to welter for one of these fights. but smh @ me even thinking you guys would possibly credit that

 

Sorry man but we discus facts not possibilities. Try to argue why Floyd has a better resume than Cotto at WW and you will fail. The same with Mosley, Oscar and Tito

 

Cory Spinks beat 2 former undisputed welterweight champions at 147. Just saying :yep