Best fighters ever by weight class

Arguello would beat the crap out of Floyd.

 

No Morales for super Batam?

I always find light welter hard to judge as it is a stepping stone division really . Chavez and Pryor are the two , but they have serious flaws in their resume's.

Chavez getting ripped apart by a 24 year old Oscar and a gift against Whittaker. Pryor really only beating one man who was a life lightweight and in very murky circumstances.

 

Not a chance. He'd be made to look like Valuev against Gomez.

Chavez's Jr. Welter resume is flawed because of his losses to Pernell at Welterweight and De La Hoya when far past his prime?

 

Minimumweight - Ricardo Lopez
Light Flyweight - Michael Carbajal
Flyweight - Miguel Canto
Super Fly - Johnny Tapia
Bantamweight - Ruben Olivares
Super-Bantam - Wilfredo Gomez
Featherweight - Salvador Sanchez
Featherweight - Salvador Sanchez
Super-Feather - Alexis Arguello
Lightweight - Roberto Duran
Light-Welter - Julio Cesar Chavez
Welter - Ray Robinson
Light-Middle - Thomas Hearns
Middle - Carlos Monzon
Super-Middle - Roy Jones
Light-Heavy - Ezzard Charles
Cruiserweight - Evander Holyfield
Heavyweight - Muhammad Ali

 

I disagree, it would be a beautifully brutal fight but I have Gomez by SD. nobody looks like snv joe

 

Ok on Morales , but Chavez even at prime was the WBC jewel and in my opinion went 0 - 3 against Randall and Whitaker.

And I know I am going to get stick for this , but I didnt have him winning against Ramirez either.

These were prime fights , Chavez was great , but I think anything close he got. Randall I was by SD and I had Randall by at least 4 or 5 rounds.

 

Perhaps you're thinking of a different fight? Chavez schooled Ramirez and stopped him. He only took the fight in the first place as a favor to Jose, who was his sparring partner.

I disagree that he was in his prime against Randall, although the rematch was a farce of the highest order and doesn't speak well of Chavez's character at all.

 

Or anyone else..

 

At Featherweight and above Morales may well have beaten him, but a prime Gomez, circa the ages of 19-22, would've boxed rings around the defensively inept Morales. Gomez is one of those fighters who started to deteriorate from a technical stand-point as his career progressed and he started believing more and more in his own KO power. You can blame the press for that. It's a shame, too, as he was about as complete and immense a boxer-puncher as I've ever seen at just 20 years old.

 

It was the fight where the fight was stopped due to a clash of heads, and the first fighter to beat Whitaker.

Maybe I am wrong , the cards were very close.

 

Chavez-Ramirez was not close at all. One-sided fight.

 

Almost the same list I have. I have Roy Jones at Super Middle though.

 

Yeah, you're wrong. The fight wasn't even remotely close. Completely different classes of fighter. Also, as I'm sure you know, Ramirez received one of the biggest gifts of all time against Whitaker in their first fight. It was worse than the Chavez robbery.

 

Carbajal would've taken a prime time whooping against Chang.

 

Like the whooping Chiquita put on Jung Koo Chang?:bbb