Duran, as great as he was, probably belongs in the 70s as the best. His win against Leonard was legendary! One thing going for him in an all time pound sense is his fight with Hagler. Of course Hagler would have tore his head off if he decided to take it to him the way he did with Hearns, but the same can likely be said regarding Leonard vs Hagler. Back to Duran, he's one of the greatest, perhaps the greatest, boxers of the 70s. I can't see anybody taking that away from him. What you said affords some opportunity for him to be considered in the 80s as well.... at least the little menace stuck his chin (weight) out and did rather well! Duran plays an important role in boxing history - the best at what he was, and giving a good showing at what he wasn't.
Not to take away from the original topic. But I think Mantequilla's point was, what a great decade the 80s was. Pick 10 Okay we can do that, but why when you have all this. Great list Now add all the fighters that were 2nd tier , there were allot of them. expecially at lightweight, welter and middle. The 80's was a golden age. The Haugens, dewiits, Hard rock Greens, Gannigans, laporte, Roldan, Benitez etc. a ton of tough folks Was a Great era and most of it on Broadcast TV in the states at the time, Closed circuit for the really big ones.
100 Miguel Lora 99 Michael Moorer 98 Hilmer Kenty 97 Rolando Navarrete 96 Yong Kang Kim 95 Gabby Canizales 94 Fulgencio Obelmejias 93 Bobby Czyz 92 Frank Tate 91 Matthew Hilton 90 Sean O'Grady 89 Terry Marsh 88 Greg Haugen 87 Duke McKenzie 86 Jorge Paez 85 Wilfred Gomez 84 Maurice Hope 83 Elly Pical 82 Saoul Mamby 81 John Mugabi 80 Eddie Mustafa Muhammad 79 Milton McCrory 78 Cornelius Boza-Edwards 77 Rafael Limon 76 Sam Serrano 75 Dave McAuley 74 Livingstone Bramble 73 Dennis Andries 72 Juan Martin Coggi 71 Sung Il Moon 70 Tony Tucker 69 Marvin Johnson 68 Gianfranco Rosi 67 Jim Watt 66 Bobby Chacon 65 Jiro Watanabe 64 Fidel Bassa 63 Seung Hoon Lee 62 Alan Minter 61 Ray Mancini 60 Dodie Penalosa 59 Juan LaPorte 58 Simon Brown 57 Ayub Kalule 56 Iran Barkley 55 Chong Pal Park 54 Carlos Deleon 53 Rocky Lockbridge 52 Barry McGuigan 51 Mark Breland 50 Charles Williams 49 Sambu Kalambay 48 Humberto Gonzales 47 Julian Jackson 46 Lloyd Honeyghan 45 Raul Perez 44 Jose Luis Ramirez 43 James McGirt 42 Tim Whitherspoon 41 Marlon Starling 40 Hilario Zapata 39 Orlando Canizales 38 Virgil Hill 37 Roger Mayweather 36 Edwin Rosario 35 Daniel Zaragoza 34 Wilfred Benitez 33 Antonio Esparragoza 32 Mathew Saad Muhammad 31 Santos Laciar 30 Meldrick Taylor 29 Dwight Muhammad Qawi 28 Gilberto Roman 27 Don Curry 26 Brian Mitchell 25 Alexis Arguello 24 Hector Camacho 23 Lupe Pintor 22 Sot Chitalada 21 Michael Nunn 20 Jeff Fenech 19 Myung Woo Yuh 18 Jung Koo Chang 17 Mike McCallum 16 Evander Holyfield 15 Pernell Whitaker 14 Jeff Chandler 13 Khoasio Galaxy 12 Salvador Sanchez 11 Azumah Nelson 10 Roberto Duran 9 Aaron Pryor 8 Eusebio Pedroza 7 Julio Cesar Chavez 6 Larry Holmes 5 Michael Spinks 4 Tommy Hearns 3 Mike Tyson 2 Marvin Hagler 1 Ray Leonard
Tyson and Holmes? Both deserved it... Spinks gets his top 10 place mainly for achievements at 175; although beating a 48-0 Holmes (twice; on paper:yep ) certainly adds to his career.
Happy Lora looked the real deal for awhile, but he exposed (Perez) before the 80s were out. Zaragoza always gave it good value and overall his career had more quality to it than Lora's.
McCallum was slightly damaged goods after the first Kalambay fight, it was felt he failed to live up to being the future of the 160lbers, and Nunn seemed the much better bet.
I was a big fan of him actually. His fights with banke and Tatsuyoshi were awesome. Erik Morales did not have an easy time with him either and that was an old washed up version.