Best five wins from the best contenders

John Ruiz
1 Evander Holyfield
2 Hasim Rahman
3 Andrew Golata
4 Tony Tucker
5 Fres Oquendo

Ruslan Chagaev
1 Nikolai Valuev
2 John Ruiz
3 Fres Oquendo
4 Francesco Pianeta
5 Kali Meehan

Oliver McCall
1 Lenox Lewis
2 Larry Holmes
3 Henry Akinwade
4 Bruce Seldon
5 Fres Oquendo

Fres Oquendo is on all three lists lol interesting. John Ruiz has a solid list. All three have an ok list really. McCalls I thought would be a little better after the first big two.

 

Any surprises for you on the lists so far?

 

Williams has a LOT of D - C fighters. Fighters maybe not known to the public but respected in the community I guess? Not much quality beyond Terrell. Bruno surprised me a little. Along w Loughran (didn’t realize he was that deep). Loughran will def be one of the tops for me. Povetkin is really deep as well. Especially for a modern fighter.

 

Going to do a number system 1-10
1Place =10
2=9
Etc
Going to wait till a minimum of ten voters over three or four days. Contemplated doing by decade but think it’s easier to do it this way.

 

I wanted to put Oleg for Oliver but I think he was only six fights deep at the time

 

Man Risko was deep. Kind of Satterfield like w his record. So many losses though

 

Valuev was undefeated while Ruiz had some wear and tare by then. At least if I’m remembering correctly. I hold Ruiz over Valuev in the grand scheme of things

 

Ok gonna make an executive decision. Going to remove Vitali. To much controversy on wether he was lineal or not. That and I think people will vote for him based on ability as opposed to resume...something he lacks (not his fault division was weak and brother was the best contender).
Going to replace him with Tim Witherspoon. But going to do it a little different have till tomorrow to vote on him because I want to keep this moving to the next stage which is the final vote! So besides Chagaev, Ruiz and McCall give me your Witherspoon votes today please