Best of last 50 years

Holmes is higher all-time than Frazier and should replace him on that list. Whitaker is too low and needs to be above both Hagler and Monzon. Foreman is too high and should be behind Arguello and Hearns if your going to include them.

Calzaghe and Hatton don't belong anywhere near a top 10.

 

Quick try.


Ali
Duran
Jones
Leonard
Whittaker
Arguello
Monzon
Spinks
JCC
Floyd Mayweather

 

Monzon ruled MW like it was his *****. As did Hagler. The mention of Calzaghe, Mayweather Jr. and Hatton was a joke (didn't you read the post?)

 

good point this list is too tough to do lol

 

mayweather jr is no joke...hatton JC yes...PBF is a top 10 guy EASY

 

Good list :good

Personally, I would squeeze Mayweather into that list, like him or not.

 

:rofl
Maybe in terms of god given ability, but PBF doesn't fight anyone who's a threat, only old fighters, or guys who come up from lower weight classes. Let him fight Margarito, Williams, etc., etc.....it will never happen.

 

Fair list.....but....

1. I would have Ali as no1
2. Barely heard of your no7 & your no8 could surely make room for a Hagler/Chavez/Mayweather type guy no ?
3. Im starting to rethink classing Duran over Leonard continously on these lists.
4. Nogeuira losing broke my ****in heart, guys a soldier. :verysad

 

You're entitled to your opinion. I wouldn't.

Perhaps that means you should do a bit of research on those fighters rather than just assuming that more famous=better.

Again, you're entitled to your opinion. I disagree.

They all get old eventually. In MMA it's all about the young guns these days.

 

There is not much at all between Leonard & Duran, its so close that it may even come down to preference.

 

One fought the other tooth and nail and loss. Then he came back and made him quit, like a ****in *****.

One was the victim of arguably the greatest KO punch in history. The other went to war and beat that guy who delivered said punch.

No contest.

Only those who have a preference for RD would even think about ranking him higher. I didn't particularly root for either, as I was always a fan of Hearns and Hagler.

 

If you're a huge fan you should know why he clearly deserves to be on the list.

 

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Eder Jofre
4. Roberto Duran
5. Willie Pep
6. Sugar Ray Leonard
7. Roy Jones
8. Bernard Hopkins
9. Pernell Whitaker
10. Marvin Hagler

 

It appears you didn't read the OP very carefully.