Best SFW win resume: Arguello, Chavez, Nelson or Mayweather?

He showed glimpses of greater talent when he used his jab and set things up with it.Too much of a liking for slugging in the end.

 

Arguello. Better opposition and he took them all out in grand fashion. From a H2H standpoint I don't see anyone of them beating Floyd.

 

I'm actually going to go against the grain and say Nelson had the best resume, as he's the only one to have beaten a fighter I consider a genuine ATG and HOFer (I know Chacon is also in the HOF, but I don't consider him an ATG). Also, I think outslugging the dynamite punching Lupe Suarez was a pretty big feat as well, as Suarez was coming off wins over JJ Molina and Juan LaPorte. In it's time, that was at least comparable to Mayweather beating Corrales or Manfredy IMO.

 

I don't. I would put Corrales more on par with someone like Bazooka Limon - a flawed, limited fighter with tremendous power who managed to pull off a few big wins despite his limitations. I'm not even sure Corrales was better than Chacon, let alone Escalera.

 

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xzocvh60xBU[/ame]

 

This content is protected

sup yo'

 

Vic,quem e a garota em seu avatar?GOSTOZA!!

 

:goodTerrific post,Duodenum.Well said.I happen to agree 100%:good

 

Victoria Villarim !
Amo ela !

 

Eu tambem!E nao a conheco.

 

Procure na internet pelo nome dela, voce vai achar muitas fotos....

 

Muito obrigado,cara.Muito amigavel:good:good

 

Tough one. Probably go Arguello since he produced the most stoppages. Quite comparable really. I enjoy watching all of them at 130.

 

Arguello is number 1 for me here, he has the best names on his record and a superb win in Chacon IMO. He looks really devastating in doing it, I mean people cite this as his prime for a reason. And he was dominant over a good era, because when he moved up you seen some good fighters emerge (Chacon, Boza and Limon).

Second I'd have to say Nelson, he had a long spell at SFW, he had solid names on the record and there are no glaring emmissions IMO. He kept his form past his best beating guys like Leija and Ruelas when way past it. On film he looks good, just inconsistent, and although he was inconsistant in performances, t his credit, he stayed very dominant.

Third I'd have Chavez mainly as I feel he has more depth than Floyd in his resume. Although they are pretty even elsewehre.

I think Floyd might be the best of the four of them though.