Better Comp? Hopkins or RJJ?

Id say jones

 

Jones, and by a ****ING MILE.

 

BHOP just fought the better names but not necessary the better comp

 

Roy Jones, Jr.

 

Hopkins has no prime, elite natural MW's or higher on his record as wins, case closed.

 

:good

 

Hopkins vs. Toney prime/prime is a toss up, I'll personally take Toney in a close UD, putting Hopkins on his ass in the process.

Hopkins wouldn't have unified LHW like Roy did, one of those guys would have beaten him in his quest.

Hopkins wouldn't have defeated Ruiz at HW.

Now, what Hopkins opponents defeat a prime Roy? None.

On top of it, Roy has a win over Hopkins. There is not a person around who can justify Hopkins' overall comp as superior to Jones and as prime fighters, they absolutely are not comparable within the 160-175 spectrum.

 

At 160 or 168? Because at 160, I would go with Hopkins by UD.

 

Hopkins pound for pound beats Toney head to head 8 times out of 10. And gets knocked down never. How can you say he gets knocked down? his chin is rock solid and its almost impossible to land flush on it.

 

Jones Jr.

 

why must you start such an evil thread lol?

 

:-(

 

Tough one.

I will go with Hopkins.