hatton is better than gatti but both are limited and neither think on their feet. but to be honest gatti was a poster child for a hard man who had absolutely no adaptability whatsoever.
Hatton by a fairly significant margin. As much as I love what Gatti brought to the ring he was a very limited action fighter who gave it his all each fight.
That's only because Gatti would beat a random stripper with it. :!: He comes with a warning label these days: "Keep me away from an open flame. Do not place me near any object that can puncture or I may explode with great force."