Better/Greater: Saldivar or Ortiz?

They are right next to each other in a p4p list imo. If I had to pick one over the other... Saldivar ... no, Ortiz ... no, Saldivar. Maybe?

 

Been working my list out for a couple of months...I was hoping I would be done by spring but I am no longer optimistic. My initial thought is both will miss the top 50 and appear in the top 75. I like Saldivar narrowly at this stage, but I am not set on it.

 

I think Ortiz is much better. Saldivar is great for sure but Ortiz is a cut above him IMO.

 

Interesting that you think neither would make top 50. Look forward to seeing your list!

 

Much better? I can see a strong argument for Ortiz above Saldivar, of course, but I don't know if I would say he was much better. Are you talking achievement or skill or both?

 

His career and achievements. I think their skills are closer than that but I still give an edge to Ortiz there too.