Better MD win (VOTE): Mayweather over Maidana or Brook over Porter

Both the same kind of level win IMO

 

kahn gave maidana a better beating than floyd ever did, so dont tell me it was a good win you pranny. :good

 

Maidana is a far better fighter nowadays than he was back in 2011-2012. :hi:

Nice try.

Everyone knows Maidana is better than Porter and you Brittards have to accept that fight. :hi:

 

Only delusional yanks think it, but in all honesty if u asked them, they know floyd took some nasty licks from a plodder like maidana, and barely hurt marcos, compare it porter who landed nothing and got countered superbly by special k and you should have only winner in the poll. Brook over Porter.

 

There's a reason why he's fighting the p4p king, because of his recent transformation and the fact that he managed to shock Broner.

Maidana is far more relevant than Brook is and the world knows it. :hi:

Most Brits know it too, only Brittards refuse to acknowledge that

 

Maidana won decisively, he was also a 5-1 underdog, it was very impressive. Broner is still a very good fighter...just jumped up too quickly

 

porter would destroy broner . thats the measuring stick you need.

 

both are good wins. but i'd give the edge to Maidana. he's a better fighter than Porter.

Brook beating Porter was more convincing than Floyd beating Maidana though.

the Porter win made a bigger splash considering most picked Porter to win, and win by stoppage. Shawn was a beast a few days ago. whereas no one picked Marcos to come close to beating Floyd.

 

No.

Maidana was around 1:5 while Brook was around 1:3.