In all honesty I enjoy watching both of these fighters but when it comes down to THE BEST OVERALL BOXER, out of these 2 who comes out on top? Not just one aspect of their skill such as defense for Floyd or Finishing skills in Pacman. I mean: 1.Ring generalship, 2.Defense,3. Power, 4.Speed, 5.Footwork, 6.Tenacity, 7.Will, 8.Accuracy, 9. Finishing skills, 10. Flexibility to change game plan during fight.