better p4p fighter right now : Khan or Cotto

I have cotto at 12 khan at 13

 

Khan at the moment

Foreman and Mayorga isnt cutting it at the moment

 

kahn clearly if we are talking about the last 3 years and i dont think its even close

 

If they were the same size, Cotto could very well beat Khan with his jab, timing, and body punching, but Khan has had the better victories over the past year or so.

 

I have to say cotto´s win over foreman is underrated, a lot of people thought cotto was shot and would get outboxed from the outside by the taller foreman.
Yet cotto won almost every round and stopped him easily, he deserves some credit for it even if foreman turned out to be nothing special.

 

Khan, Cotto hasn't beat anyone noteworthy since Margarito wooped him.

 

On an all time list ill take Cotto.

As far as currently... I have Kahn over Cotto.

 

Khan's recent run has been more impressive, but I thought P4P rankings taking into account more than just recent performances? In which case, Cotto is easily above Khan. Even as a fighter, at 147, I think Cotto would beat Khan in a very competitive, entertaining, FOTY type fight.

 

I am not so sure. I genuinely don't think that Cotto is the same animal that he once was. He has not looked any where near the level he was in the last yr or so. I think Khan wins a very close fight at 147. All that said, this is rather premature. We haven't even seen Khan fight once at 147. Alot of assumptions to make any accurate predictions to be honest.

 

cotto - 9
Khan - 13

P4P list
1.Manny Pacquiao - 51-3-2, 38KOs
2. Sergio Martinez 46-2-2, 25KOs
3.Juan M. Marquez - 51-5-1, 37KOs
4.Nonito Donaire - 24-1, 16KOs
5.Wladimir Klitscko 56-3-0, 49 KOs
6.Bernard Hopkins 51-5-1, 32KOs
7.Pong.Wonjongkam 78-3-1, 42 KOs
8.Giovani Segura 26-1-1, 22 KOs
9.Miguel Cotto - 35-2, 28KOs
10.Andre Ward - 23-0, 13 KOs
11.Yuriorkis Gamboa - 20-0 16KOs
12.Carl Froch - 28-1 20KOs
13.Amir Khan - 26-1 18KOs
14.Lucian Bute - 28-0 23KOs
15.Timothy Bradley - 27-0 11KOs

 

True. I just think Cotto would be better at 147 than he is at 154. We have to wait and see what Khan would be like at 147 to give a more accurate prediction.