Better Performance: PBF (against castillo 1) or PACQUIAO (against morales 1)

No, you're twisting my words - in the subject of which performance was better - (obviously - you need to have some form of standard - like for like, a shitty performance against a debutant and winning a sd, or a guy pushing prime rjj to the limit and losing on a sd - there's got to be some consideration, however - like for like) in a like for like - similar level in relevant terms - the winner comes off better. duran gets more credit from me for beating leonard, than either hearns or hagler for pushing leonard to the limit.

 

Mayweather won his fight...Pac lost..if your talking about exciting fights than I'd say Pac-Morales was more exciting..If your talking about the greater performance than I'd say the Pretty Boy takes it...Floyd was hurt and found a way to win...Pac lost...

I'd say Morales performance against Pac is just as good if not bettter than Floyds win over Castillo however...Comparing Morales in the 1st fight is better than comparing Pac!

 

both fought well imo. floyd seemed lost and still gave castillo a close fight in which castillo was robbed by the judges. floyd ,didn't seem like he was looking to win and seemed out of it. manny on the other hand, kept pressuring and looking for any opportunity for erik to make a mistake, even up to the final round. manny had a better losing performance. and yes, CASTILLO WAS ROBBED!!!

 

pbf, pac lost

 

Void lost the first fight with Castillo, that's why a rematch was ordered. Shame of the criminal judges.

 

In that case, your reasoning is flawed too. because looking good depends on whom you are fighting. I sided with Floyd with this one because i thought Pac fought and looked good because he and EM complimented each others styles and it looked like a war. Wherein Floyd against Castillo were'nt as good. But where did Floyd really fought that was made to look like war?? So if i was to guage the fight, both didnt look as impressive as their usual self, but in this case, Floyd managed to win and Pac didnt. If Pac won it, my vote goes to him, simply because i like the way they fought.

 

i may agree with the underlined.

we may just have to take opposite sides on the topic tho.

 

He was elite, it just shows the critics don't know what the hell they are talking about sometimes. It shows how underrated he was.

If anything, those fights, showed clearly how good Castillo was, even if Mayweather was hurt, so wasn't at his best. And afterwards what did Castillo do? Came back and beat other elites.

 

Floyd showed heart in that fight, where he was injured. Sure he didn't fight like his normal self, but he couldn't -- he did what he had to in order to win. He showed heart. He fought through his injury although you could clearly see how affected he was by it and had to dig deep for it against a monster in there on that night.