Better Record at HW, Haye or Adamek?

Golota>Bonin
Estrada>Barett
Arreola>Valuev

Still Haye has 1 fight more (Ruiz). To me its equal.

 

When Haye made a decision he is moving up to heavyweight I wanted to see him against these young guys like Estrada, Chambers, Arreola, Povetkin. Instead he fought hasbeens and Valuev. So far I am dissapointed but he looked phenomenal beating those has beens.

 

Golata, Bonin, and Barrett don't count... But Valuev + Ruiz > Estrada + Arreola.

 

Arreola beats Valuev, Ruiz, Barrett and Bonin. Does he beat Haye? He isn't without a chance. He has chin, aggressivness and stamina to wear down Haye.

Golota>Bonin

Estrada>Ruiz, Estrada is very game and in his prime, Ruiz in big decline and fighting "pretty" against Haye

Arreola>Valuev

 

I respect Haye for beating Valuev, but to be honest Holy beat Valuev 1 year before. And Ruiz is way past it.

 

haye IMO but wud love to see these face off

 

I like adamek and believe he could wear haye down and stop him but haye has the speed to land flush with his bombs and when that happens i don't know what happens???????? adamek was wary of tubb's power and he wasn't badly hurt but tubbs didn't land cleanly.

 

Haye, but not by such huge leaps and bounds or anything.

 

If Haye had a chin of steel he'd be a huge huge prospect.

 

Adamek because Arreola is the best HW by far on that list.

 

I'd say Haye based on the wins against Valuev and Ruiz. While neither fighter was at their best they were at least proven at the top level in the current heavyweight division.

I picked Adamek to easily outpoint Arreola as I have never been impressed by Arreola. How beating a retired 38 year old McCline and the son of Tim Witherspoon some how makes you a serious contender is beyond me. I wouldn't rate Arreola as being much better than Estrada to be honest. This isn't a knock on Adamek he is a very good fighter and has impressed me so far which is why I knew he would handle anything Arreola could bring.

 

Why do people actually think Arreola is good? I don't understand where this has come from, he has never even looked that good when winning!!!

 

Thank you another person who hasn't fallen for the hype. Wouldn't shock me if Arreola never beat a top ten heavy he has done nothing to suggest that he should have even be regarded as a serious contender.

 

Good call.

I also think Adamek had the better cruiserweight resume of the 2.