Better resume at HW: Vitali or Haye?

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Boom1989, Mar 1, 2013.


  1. Boom1989

    Boom1989 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,102
    0
    Mar 26, 2011
    David Haye has had seven fights at heavyweight, against the following boxers:

    Dereck Chisora - dominated him like no other heavyweight ever managed to do, including Fury, Helenius or Klitschko.

    Wladimir Klitschko - lost a decision against the #1 hw in the world

    Audley Harrison - ridiculous fight, but still an easy win over a former olympic gold medalist; and Harrison seems to be having quite a comeback here.

    John Ruiz - incredibly underrated due to his ugly fighting style; but since Tua nobody manhandled him the way Haye did.

    Nikolay Valuev - easily outpointed the giant with very little effort.

    Monte Barrett - no big win as it seems, but let's not forget what Barrett did to David Tua later on.

    Tomasz Bonin - don't know a thing about Bonin.

    In my opinion the seven best boxers Vitali has faced are the following:

    Chris Byrd - won most of the rounds but did not out-strike Byrd, quit after round 9. The punch stats sugggest the bout was fairly even.

    Dereck Chisora - see below

    Lennox Lewis - won 4 of the 6 rounds which is a great achievement but failed to get the job done and lost fair and square. Lewis coming off a one year lay off at age 38.

    Kirk Johnson - big win, would be a huge win had Johnson not come in hella fat.

    Corrie Sanders - very good win; but I feel Sanders in overrated after his win over Wladimir. Sanders just never was that great to begin with. R.I.P.

    Samuel Peter - good win, but Peter had already been deteriorating for quite a while. He was much better against Wladimir because he did not give a **** about boxing, he was a genuine fighter back then.

    Chris Arreola - good win, dominated him. But Arreola is as one dimensional as it gets.

    I do not count the Solis and Adamek fights in this very context because I would argue Adamek simply does not belong in the heavyweight division at all and the Solis fight ended due to a freak accident.

    Dereck Chisora is a common opponent of the two. David dominated and stopped him whereas Vitali, to be frank, went life and death with him.

    Who has the better resume at HW?
     
  2. larryx2012

    larryx2012 I AM BETTER THEN YOU Full Member

    12,523
    33
    May 24, 2012