Better Resume? Floyd or Calzaghe

Corrales KO10 better than Roy Jones UD

Hatton KO10 better than Kessler UD

Arturo Gatti TKO6 better than Lacy UD

 

calzaghe all day. Floyd fought 1 legit welterweight, not good enough.

 

Obviously Mayweather's resume is much better.

Old Eubank
Lacy
Kessler
Old Hopkins
Shot Jones

vs.

G. Hernandez
Corrales
Jesus Chavez
Castillo
Castillo
Old De la Hoya
Hatton

 

What about the other 4 divisions at which he fought? And he did manage to win 2 titles at WW.

 

Thankyou

I do agree on PBF hands down just not sure about a couple of the above examples

 

Floyd by some distance.

 

Peter Manfredo adds weight to Calzaghes resume

 

It would have been a LOT trickier for Joe to do that;SM-LH-CW-HW(Which is just 4)is different to the few pounds of the lower weights.

 

be more specific.

and anyways i don't think Floyd's resume is lightyears ahead of Calzaghe's just better but not by much..

For example Corrales better than Roy Jones? Thats debatable. Roy Jones was shot but Corrales was ****ed up on the night too. Way off his best as he was having many problems outside the ring and it showed.

Gatti better than Lacy thats debatable, Gatti was shot at the time although bigger than Floyd.

Hatton better than Kessler thats also debatable. Floyd also made Hatton move up to WW.

and Floyd has never fought anyone as good as the Hopkins that Calzaghe beat.

Oscar was shot and inactive but much bigger.

Castillo was pretty much on par with Mayweather at 135.

Hernandez' best win was an SD on a 39 year old Azumah Nelson where he almost got ktfo. Oscar completely destroyed him years before Floyd did in his last fight.

 

that really makes a big difference. duh?

 

Yeah but look at how he avoided all the big names at welterweight. turned down 8 mil to fight margarito. what about cotto, mosley etc

 

that's the summary there...:deal

 

Put it this way, Calzaghe probably challenged himself more in say, 2 individual fights - Hopkins and Kessler.

Looking at it that way, they were harder fights for Calzaghe than any fight Mayweather took, if that makes sense. However, that is partly due to Mayweathers superiority as a fighter.

In a nutshell, PBF's resume shits on Calzaghe's. His resume is deep, just lacks a couple of career defining wins that make an old school great.

 

pbf no contest..

 

Would of been even better if he fought as long as Calzaghe did.