Better Resume: Manny Pacquiao or Pernell Whitaker?

whittaker fights and beats prime at their best fighters, pacquiao fights shot past their prime and at the same time dehydrated fighters with a rehydration clause

 

Ledwaba was a world champion, a top 15 pound for pound fighter, 33-1-1, when he fought a green Manny Pacquiao, who took the fight on 2 weeks notice, and did this to him...

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gASk2E1Ih68[/ame]

 

nvm just add Ledwaba to Pac's wins. Take David Diaz off.

 

David Diaz should have never been on the list

 

good now it's settled.

 

in fairness to ledwaba he didn't enough time to prepare for pac's speed and power.

 

In all fairness to Ledwaba he's a bum.

 

4 best fighters IMO of the last 20-25 years.



PERNELL WHITAKER


Roger Mayweather - (1987, Lightweight, UD)

Greg Haugen - (1989, Lightweight, UD)

Jose Luis Ramirez (1989, Lightweight, UD)

Azumah Nelson - (1990, Lightweight, UD)

Anthony Jones - (1991, Lightweight, UD)

Jorge Paez - (1991, Lightweight, UD)

Rafael Pineda (1992, Light Welterweight, UD)

James McGirt - (1993, Welterweight, UD)

Santos Cardona - (1994, Welterweight, UD)

James McGirt - (1994, Welterweight, UD)

Julio Cesar Vasquez - (1995, Light Middleweight, UD)

Jake Rodriguez - (1995, Welterweight, KO6)

Wilfredo Rivera - (1996, Welterweight, SD)

Wilfredo Rivera - (1996, Welterweight, UD)

Diosbelys Hurtado - (1997, Welterweight, TKO11)


DRAW - Julio Cesar Chavez (1993, Welterweight)




MANNY PACQUAIO


Chatchai Sasakul - (1998, Flyweight, KO8)

Lehlohonolo Ledwaba - (2001, Super Bantamweight, TKO6)

Marco Antonio Barerra - (2003, Featherweight, TKO11)

Erik Morales - (2006, Super Featherweight, TKO10)

Oscar Larios - (2006, Super Featherweight, UD)

Erik Morales - (2006, Super Featherweight, KO3)

Marco Antonio Barrera - (2007, Super Featherweight, UD)

Juan Manuel Marquez - (2008, Super Featherweight, SD)

Oscar De La Hoya - (2008, Catch Weight 145, TKO8)

Ricky Hatton - (2009, Light Welterweight, KO2)

Miguel Cotto - (2009, Catch Weight 145, TKO12)

Joshua Clottey - (2010, Welterweight, UD)


DRAW - Agapito Sanchez (2001, Super Bantamweight), Juan Manuel Marquez (2004, Featherweight)




EVANDER HOLYFIELD
*all fighters not marked with a weight are obviously Heavyweights



Dwight Muhammed Qawi - (1986, Cruiserweight, SD)

Ossie Ocasio - (1987, Cruiserweight, TKO11)

Carlos De Leon - (1988, Cruiserweight, TKO8)

Dwight Muhammed Qawi - (1987, Cruiserweight, KO4)

Pinkon Thomas - (1988, TKO7)

Michael Dokes - (1989, TKO10)

James Buster Douglas - (1990, KO3)

George Foreman - (1991, UD)

Larry Holmes - (1992, UD)

Riddick Bowe - (1993, MD)

Ray Mercer (1995, UD)

Bobby Czyz (1996, TKO5)

Mike Tyson - (1996, TKO11)

Mike Tyson - (1996, DQ)

Michael Moorer - (1997, TKO8)

John Ruiz - (2000, UD)

Hasim Rahman - (2002, TD)


DRAW - Lennox Lewis (1999), John Ruiz (2001)




ROY JONES JR.


Jorge Vaca - (1992, Middleweight, KO1)

Jorge Castro - (1992, Middleweight, UD)

Bernard Hopkins - (1993, Middleweight, UD)

Thulani Malinga - (1993, Super Middleweight, KO6)

Thomas Tate - (1994, Middleweight, TKO2)

James Toney - (1994, Super Middleweight, UD)

Vinny Pazienza - (1995, Super Middleweight, TKO6)

Tony Thornton - (1995, Super Middleweight, TKO3)

Merqui Sosa - (1996, Light Heavyweight, TKO2)

Mike McCallum - (1996, Light Heavyweight, UD)

Montell Griffin - (1997, Light Heavyweight, KO1)

Virgil Hill - (1998, Light Heavyweight, KO4)

Reggie Johnson - (1999, Light Heavyweight, UD)

Eric Harding - (2000, Light Heavyweight, TKO10)

Julio Cesar Gonzalez - (2001, Light Heavyweight, UD)

Clinton Woods - (2002, Light Heavyweight, TKO6)

John Ruiz - (2003, Heavyweight, UD)

Antonio Tarver - (2003, Light Heavyweight, MD)

 

For those of you voting for Pacquiao. Who dose he have besides Bareera (1 )and Hatton? oh and Maybe his slight win over Marquez (2)? Anyone else you can bring up was weight drianed, past his prime or just not that good.
Whatiaker's resume is much better with Azumah Nelson, James McGirt(1,2), Julio Cesar Vasquez. I could add his win over Jose Luis Ramirez as well not to mention his draw to Julio Cesar Chavez.

 

pacquiao and its not even close.

 

didnt ali or duran did that?

 

i love how you list pacquiao-oscar at a catchweight fight of 145 when it was really for a 147 fight while ignoring that chavez-whitaker was at catchweight of 145.

 

Oscar was fought his last fight at 150 and was planning to fight at at 147 for his next fight, and he did, it was contracted for 147. So dlh drops 3lbs and PAC jumps 12lbs with PAC being ridiculed apparently walking for a payday as he will get killed. He shocks the world and suddenly it's not a great win?lol.