Better Resume: Morales,Chavez,Mayweather,Pacquiao,Sugar Ray Leonard or Cotto?

Agreed. Hell, even Stallone is in a hall of famer, lol.

Robinson had the greatest skill set of any fighter in the history of the sweet science. That is why I rate Robinson #1 pound for pound and Greb #2. :good

 

I think he definitely had the greatest combination of power, speed and chin (as one package). I have no doubt Gavilan would be the best fighter on the planet were he fighting today. Robinson does appear to be several generations ahead of his time if only athletically compared to most of his oppo, though he undoubtedly built a far deeper resume than Leonard. SRL can however, hang with anybody as far as very best wins are concerned though IMO.

 

This is right.

Manny is above Mayweather, however much I love Mayweather, Manny is the 8 division champ and has beat everyone from Sasakul to Margarito. That is mental. Mayweather, although the best superfeatherweight of all time, had a dead reign until he beat Hatton and then Cotto.

 

Srl
jcc
em
mp
mc
fmj

 

the list to me is
Leonard
Pacman
Chavez
Morales
Mayweather
Cotto I think Cotto could be left out of this list. I love Miguel, but he does not belong here.

 

Lol, if this were on scene Manny would be winning by like 40 votes :rofl

 

Considering the top 10 wins of each and belts won :

Sugar Ray Leonard

4 Weight world champion

Welterweight champion (WBC/WBA) Middleweight champion (WBC), Supermiddleweight champion (WBC) and technically light heavyweight champion (WBC)

Duran 3x, Hearns 2x, Hagler, Benitez, Lalonde, Hill, Norris

6 wins, 3 losses, 1 draw, 3 knockouts, 2 close decisions, 2 losses came at the end of his career

Julio Cesar Chavez

3 Weight world champion

Superfeather weight champion (WBC) Lightweight champion (WBC/WBA) Lightwelterweight champion (WBC/IBF)

Taylor 2x, Whitaker, De La Hoya 2x, Randal 3x, Mayweather, Tszyu

5 wins, 4 losses, 1 draw 2 KO wins, 3 KO losses, 1 controversial decision and 1 controversial stoppage

Floyd Mayweather

5 Weight world champion

Super featherweight (WBC) Lightweight (WBC) Light Welterweight (WBC) Welterweight (WBC/IBF) Light Middleweight (WBC/WBA)

De La Hoya, Hatton, Mosley, Cotto, Corralles, Castillo 2x, Judah, Marquez, Hernandez

10 wins, 3 Ko wins, 1 close decision and still on going

Manny Pacquiao

6 Weight world champion

Flyweight (WBC) Superbantamweight (IBF) Super featherweight (WBC) Lightweight (WBC) Welterweight (WBO) Light Middleweight (WBC)

Morales 3x, Barrera 2x, Marquez 4x Cotto

7 wins, 2 losses, 1 draw, 4 ko wins, 1 ko loss, 3 close decisions

Erik Morales

4 weight world champion

Super Bantamweight (WBC/WBO) Featherweight (WBC) Super Feather weight (WBC/IBF) Light welterweight (WBC)

Zargoza, Barrera 3x, Pacquiao 3x, Jones, Garcia 2x

4 wins, 6 losses, 2 Ko wins, 4 Ko Losses, 2 close decisions. 2 losses at end of career

Miguel Cotto

3 Weight world champion

Light welterweight champion (WBO) Welterweight (WBA/WBO) Light middleweight (WBA)

Margarito 2x, Pacquiao, Mayweather, Clottey, Judah, Mallignaggi, Quintana, Mosley

6 wins, 4 losses, 3 ko wins, 2 ko losses

Mayweather is the only one who went 10-0
Pacquiao held the most belts at the most weights and most stoppages but also the most controversey
Leonard had the more meaningful fights (despite most being rematches)

 

Nope.

 

maybe wont so a mile, but this

 

1. Sugar Ray Leonard
2. Julio Cesar Chavez
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Floyd Mayweather Jr
5. Erik Morales
6. Miguel Cotto

 

Manny = Flyweight, Bantamweight, Superbantamweight, Featherweight, Superfeatherweight, Lightweight, Light Welterweight, Welterweight, Light Middleweight champion
= 8 divisions (if you include IBO light welterweight title with Ricky Hatton)
Complete monster.