Peter's resume gets massively underrated on this forum. Let's break this down: Wins over top 5 hws at time of bout: Peter: Maskaev, Toneyx2 Haye: Valuev Wins over fringe top 10-15 hw's Peter: McCline Haye: Chisora Wins over top 15-30 hws Peter: Williams, Shufford, Diaz Haye: Ruiz, Barrett, Harrison Near victories over hw atgs: Peter: Wlad I Haye 0 Peter also had some wins over quality hw journeymen that Haye never had as well. Peter lost a couple more times at HW, but that's because he faced atgs more and also just plain faced contenders more often than Haye. Can't see how Peter doesn't get more respect than Haye on resume.
Haye. Because he made $30 million dollars without going about it the hard way. Peter had to work 5x as hard just to let Don King rip him off. Haye talked his way into so much money he took 4 years off or something like that.