Brook beat a lot of fringe contenders/decent journeymen. Wilder beat a lot of low-level clubfighters, old shot boxers and short fat former middleweights.
Brook easily, but that says more about the weakness of Wilders opponents than the strength of Brook's
I voted Wilder simply because he is pro since end of 2008, while Brook is since 2004 10 years and still didnt step upatsch I'm telling you Brook makes Wilder look good, and that aint easy:yep If Wilder doesnt step up until 2018 he will be Brook 2.0 lol