Better victories: Pac over Morales and Barrera or Floyd over Chico and Castillo

Pac's just about, but only because of how good Barrera was at that time.

I would say, Morales = Corrales and Barrera>Castillo.

So Pac would have it.

 

Pac's win over Barrera and Morales.

Simply because IMO Floyd lost to Castillo in the first fight.

Also... MAB and EM are better fights thaN Chico and JLC.

 

:nono both. if anything, both mab and erik were higher skilled than both chico and jlc. there was word that the smaller mab was beating chico in sparring, and as good as jlc was, both he and chico were never as consistent as mab or erik. jlc had some early losses to javier jauregui and cesar soto and other fighters, while you can make the argument about mab's loss to junior jones, but lost a disputed rematch afterwards. i do give floyd credit for giving jlc the rematch and probably putting on his best performance. i think that win over a prime jlc was better than the one over hatton

 

Yes, you do.

 

Who'd you think you are

 

You're exposing yourself.

"Show me you're scorecard" atsch

DICK.

 

Pac over Morales and Berrera.

 

I voted `Floyd over Castillo & Chico` even tho I regard Morales & Barrera as better fighters than Castillo & Corrales.... let me explain....

The 2 versions of Morales that Pac beat were poor compared to the prime version.
The 1st Barrera victory was amazing, better than any single victory Floyd has probably but the other Barrera victory was vs a past prime version.

Mayweather beat a prime Castillo twice, tho the 1st one was debatable & beat an undefeated prime Corrales.

The difference is WHEN these fights took place IMO, not WHO they were against.

Pac has 1 prime Barrera win vs 3 prime wins for Floyd with Castillo & Chico.

:good

 

Castillo lost to Ricky Hatton. He lost to RICKY HATTON.