I've always favoured Judah over Hatton due to stylistic reasons, although Ricky probably has the edge in terms of resume.
Ricky's dumb ass did everything Floyd Sr. told him "not to do!" Stood right in front of Pac with no head movement! Dumb! This is Ricky's lack of ability!
Hatton was a very very good amateur for somebody who didn't have good boxing skill, but then again, many americans did think malignaggi was the better boxer of the two (lol) despite Hatton having the much better amateur and professional career of the two, and even the better boxing performances. Hatton was forced to box vs Tackie and Magee and did it very very well. Ricky Hatton could box make no mistake about it