Better WW resume: FLoyd or Margo?

yep. but he is supposed to be one-dimnsional and so that does not count.

 

Eze, just curious, is the girl in your avatar wasted? She looks it.......

 

She's probably high.

 

Floyd easily.


I scored Clottey vs Margarito a draw btw. Clottey was dominating before he got injured.

 

Margarito is arguably the most accomplished welter since the Tito, DLH, Quartey, Whitaker days. 3 time champ (WBO, IBF, WBA), 7 defences (WBO). Fought all the top fighters (P.Will, Cotto, Pacquiao, Mosley, Cintron, Clottey). Hell of a welter resume.

 

I am a Margarito fan but this thread is ridiculous

 

This is weleterweight division?

Gayweather has Baldomir, Mosley, JMM, Hatton, Ortiz.

Margarito has been a career welter so the list is quite long for me to type.

Aere we actually trying to compare welterweights resume?

 

Margarito has clearly fought the better opposition. If you are going strictly by opponents faced than you have to favor Antonio.

 

What exactly is the other way?

Out of the 7 opponents Mayweather faced as welterweight, 2 are never actually been welterweights.



You have Baldomir _ even granting he was the linear welterweight champion. You can tick it as a great win if you want.

Mitchell - 1 fight at welterweight prior to facing Mayweather, KOed by Tszyu 2 fights before.

Judah - Is there a need to explain? 7 fights as welter before Mayweather

Hatton - 1 fight at welter against Collazo

JMM - no fght ever at welterweight

Shane Mosley - granting it is a very very good win.

Ortiz - 1 fight at welter (although EZE will argue that he actually fought several timesabove 140 - again granting that was the case- he fought nobodies in those fights.


7 fights as welterweight. If you disregard the numebr of fights Baldomir and Mosley had fought as welterweights, He actually fought 5 opponents whose combined welterweight resume is less than 10 fights.


Margarito never won all of his fights, but come one, are we really trying to compare his welterweight resume with that of Mayweather? Mayweather was great in a different division, but *****s would make him great as welterweight too.

By the same virtue, if you base it on him being undefeated, then his junior welterweight resume is greater than Ricky Hatton?

 

What welterweight resume? Besides beating Cotto with bricks for gloves? Name one win on his resume thats any good? Clottey? Who lost to Baldomir? Sergio Martinez before he was actually good?


Stop talking *******.

 

You should add the Martinez win for Margo. :good

 

Mayweather has been fighting fighters from lower weights at WW Margo fought all the top dogs at this weight.:deal

 

Martinez now would **** Margarito in the ass like that guido got it in American Me.

Martinez then was a novice with 3 years professional experience. Laughable for Margarito fans to claim it as a credible win.

 

Yeah and accept for the times he used his brick gloves he got his ass beat.


Mayweather schooled the guy who made Margarito his *****. Nuff said.

 

Martinez
Cintron
Clottey
Williams
Cotto
Mosley

And you can maybe say Pacman doesn't get any better then this.:deal