**bigger robbery desicion: PBF v. JLC I or JMM v. Pacquiao I?**

Bigger.
Not biggest.

 

Neither.

Those were close fights that could've gone either way (so was Pac-JMM 2 for that matter), regardless of what a meaningless system like Compubox said.

Fights like Ramirez-Whitaker 1, Escalera-Everett, Holyfield-Lewis 1 are among the biggest robberies ever.

 

neither

 

Castillo scorecards read like outright corruption. 115-111? GTFO. Castillo won that fight 7 rounds to 5.

Pac was robbed of a point which he unequivocally earned and which would make him the winner but at least that was an honest mistake.

 

Which way are you thinking JMM v Pac I should have went?

I thought JMM won both fights. It's been awhile since I've watched them though.. I thought really outside of the KD's JMM made Pac look outright ordinary.

 

Floyd hate is strong here lol, that fight could of went 7/5 either way, Manny clearly lost 10 rounds in the first Marquez fight but hey thats me and my opinion.

 

I had no problem with the decisions in either fight. Neither was a robbery. Castillo gave away way too many early rounds to win the fight on my card. I kind of wish Mayweather had lost, because I think the "0" has made him too careful in some of his opponent selections, but Castillo did **** all in the first few rounds. He didn't even dominate the latter rounds either nor land consistently. Compubox pollutes people's minds just like HBO's Legendary Myths.

I had Pacquiao winning by a point in the first fight, but there were several close rounds. Pacquiao kicked Marquez up in round 1, the second round was close, Marquez controlled rounds 3 through 7 (there was one close round in there IIRC), then no one really established control in the last 5 rounds. Most of those were close rounds. The one judge ****ed up by having it 10-7 and not knowing you could do a 10-6, but I'm sure he scored some rounds for Pacquiao where you can make a reasonable argument that Marquez won that round. And vice versa. It was that type of fight.

 

May-Castillo
10-9
10-9
10-9
10-9
10-9
Either way for round 6
9-10
9-9
9-10
9-9
9-10
9-10

 

Pacquiao was genuinely robbed in the first fight because of a scoring error. However, I think it was a close fight and you can't argue with any decision.

I had Castillo beating Mayweather in a close yet clear manner.