Bigger Win: Hatton RTD11 Tszyu or Pacquiao RTD8 Dela Hoya?

Hatton by a country mile

 

Pacquiao. He came up 2 weights and it was far more dominant

 

Pacman.

 

Beating a dehydrated ghost suffering from malnutrition isn't even as good as hatton's victory over carlos vilches

 

Hatton no question. So what if Pacquiao jumped two weight classes to face Oscar, Tszyu was the MAN at that weight and he was not weight drained. And to add further injury, Oscar's last fight before Pac was against the almighty Forbes, in which Oscar looked like crap, while Tszyu was coming off a KO win over Mitchell.

End thread.

 

/End thread

 

Hatton easily.

The manner of Pacquiao's win over DLH was very impressive, but it was a 147lb Oscar - he had to strip naked to make that against Tito nearly ten years previous.

Tszyu was past his best and Hatton got away with a few things, but Tszyu wasn't an angel in there either - and was THE MAN in the division.

Pacquiao's win over Cotto stumps Hatton vs Tszyu, even taking into account the bull**** weight imposed on Cotto.

 

Hatton.

 

Hatton.

Pacquiao moved up two weight classes which was impressive, but people also fail to mention that De La Hoya moved down a weight class...it wasn't as one-sided as the bout, De La Hoya had to give ground too.

 

hatton their not in the same ballpark

 

Imo Hattons win is a lot better, People would probably call Pacquiaos win better because he beat a man a lot bigger. But De La Hoya was weight drained fighting at a weight he had not been at in 7 years. He was past his prime aswell and his previous win against Forbes was a bit lackluster. Tszyzu while probably a bit past his prime himself was coming off an impressive win over Mitchell and wazs still the best light-welterweight at that time. This was also hattons first fight at world class so he was inexprienced.

 

:good Good post.

 

Pac's "beating a dehydrated ghost suffering from malnutrition" had proven that he can fight at the higher division. And so after the DLH fight, the Hatton fight came, followed by fights against cotto, clottey, margarito, and now mosley. Pac remains the p4p, became the fighter of the decade, and an all time great. So again ask yourself, which of these fights has the bigger win?:smoke

 

DLH won 2 seconds of that fight. It was a complete massacre and Pac had the handicap of punching up. This fight exposed and opened the door for Pac as a living legend.