Bill Gallo has Pac in the top 3 ATG, Is there any boxing historian more credible?

You are the folly of mankind.

 

Asero 2 weeks ago you would called him a hater overlooking the timelessness of Manny...now he is the most credible boxing historian of all time?

Doesnt this guy draw cartoons for a living?

 

I only listen to Roger Mayweather as a boxing historian...Roger Mayweather and Elie Seckbach...

 

I guess he just forgot to add a "0".

Seriously, Pac is awesome, he has a great career and achievement wise he is close to the best but he lacks the resume to be ranked up there. Put his resume into context, compare it with that of the other fighters in consideration, fire up your brain, use some common sense and you´ll see.

 

I agree, but let's say he beats Mayweather and Martinez before retiring, where do you feel would be a credible ranking for him then? I don't think top 10 is out of the question at all.

 

If he beats Mayweather and Martinez I think it'll be hard placing him outside the top ten.

 

I don´t think he will beat either one. Both are favs for me, so if he beats them it would be huge. I´m very sure it won´t happen though. If Williams beats Martinez, I can see Pac beating Williams for the mw title. That would be huge too. Achievementwise he would be up there with Armstrong but his resume still lacks. Top15 I think would be fair.

 

i think pac beats them both,theyre not on pacs level.pac punishes them both.

 

lol top 3 is ****en ridiculously hillarious.

Anyways if he does beat Mayweather and Martinez/Williams he is top 10 for sure.

 

Who knows? It's all based on opinion.

 

Keep this garbage in the General forum...

 

Top 3? Could he defeat a prime Roberto Duran. Ray Robinson or Ray Leonard? there are a few more in the Light. to Welter. divisions who would be favored over Pacquaio. He's a great fighter, but not top 3 IMO.

 

I think pac should be the fav over mayweather as for sergio martinez.... I dont know.