Boxercise Ben

Discussion in 'British Boxing Forum' started by BaronSamedi, Sep 21, 2024.


  1. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    This isnt coming to a conclusion based off of a single fight

    It is how almost all of boxercises fighters end up. They either get a horrific beating, and pull out a hail mary which is the most common. They get a beating and lose. They get the sent in with the total wrong tactics and lose. Or they just look poor

    As someone else mentioned hes had the cream of the crop of UK talent, AJ, Fury, BJS, Josh Taylor and all of them have looked horrible under him

    AJ fights a few bums and wins, fights real compeition and looks the worst he ever has, gets the worst beating of his life and face planted KO

    Fury looked terrible in all his fights under Ben, besides the wilder one, in which ben got the tactics on how to beat wilder totally wrong and didnt realise that pushing him onto his back foot is when hes least dangerous

    BJS looked like absolute dirt numerous times under him, getting rocked and almost losing to two foreign bums

    Josh Taylor one of the best inside fighters was made to drop his inside fighting and work at range under ben which alos made him look like ****

    These are the elite fighters and he somehow makes them worse. Yet stands so smugly and proclaims other Uk trainers arent on par with im and are lazy and hes some sort of new age wizard with his "tape study tactics"

    The proof is all there with the fights hes been involved in.

    The only times ive seen his fighters actually do well is in fights where there opponents are grossly overmatched from the off. If we look at actual perfomances of his fighters in real fights, then its clear as day hes a bad to very bad trainer.
     
    pow likes this.
  2. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    This is about as accurate and to the point as it gets
     
  3. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    he was doing that under boxercise because he was facing an extremely limited opposition who he could toy with and execute whatever he wanted to at will. niether deserve any plaudits for those 3 bums he knocked over
     
    Beale likes this.
  4. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    Joshua is definitely poor

    Boxercise exacerbated this though, enhanced his level of poor to very poor
     
  5. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    Fury and Chisora is a poor example, Chisora is vastly outmatched, physically and mentally vs fury theres nothing you can really do with such limitations

    Dubois and Aj on the other hand are very evenly matched and in an evenly matched contest, boxercises fighter got absolutely pummeled.

    Bare in mind the vast majority of experts and public had Aj, and the bookies had him 4/1 on

    On top of that AJ said hed sparred loads of rounds with Dubois, was very familiar with him and you could tell he wasnt worried about him at all. Even richie woodall who overseen some of the spars was saying AJ was looking out for Dubois in the spars. So sounds like AJ got the better of him most of the time

    Yet despite all this, it went so horrifically wrong, worse than anything ever seen before. Whats new, what changed? Boxercise was in charge
     
    Last edited: Sep 24, 2024
  6. bbjc

    bbjc Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,726
    4,563
    Feb 25, 2012
    Billy joe and fury we,re in horrendous condition when they went to ben. Actually pretty ridiculous that furys come back from 24 stone is viewed as a negative for ben davidson and pretty much shows the bias shown because we dont like the guy. I dont like him either tbh.....but it ridiculous to discedit him for fury.

    Aj looked just as bad numerous times namely against ruiz. But no one is blaming mcCracken because no one dislikes mcCraken.

    Josh taylor didnt get any better after davidson. He was too tight at the weight by that point and got worse after davidson.

    Very few trainers are able to take a fighter and get rid of their flaws when the opposition is the top level or things like weight making comes into play.

    No one is saying ben is the second coming....but he,s also not a fitness coach either. Dubois was faster....more powerful....stronger....more fluid.....and joshua,s athletism looks on the wane at 35.....stick the next guy in joshuas corner.....he,ll always have a great punchers chance in a rematch because hes a strong hitter but probably the same chance he ended up having under davidson. Dubois got to him first.
     
  7. bbjc

    bbjc Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,726
    4,563
    Feb 25, 2012

    For that to be true....we have to ignore the whole times it went just as bad for joshua from way back in the amatuers. Too a novice dillon whyte....too a 41 year old klitchko...too a grossly overweight ruiz....too usyk. He had to run away all night jabbing and grabbing an even more grossly overweight guy the second time round that was a bigger underdog....who,d humiliated him to the world to get the win.

    Outside of that we,re left with a collection of older men that his athletism could handle.

    Are we saying mcCrackens useless because ruiz a bigger underdog bounced him about the ring?

    How many trainers has he tried now? He doesnt have it is the truth. Its not his fault....its not bens fault his athletism wasnt quite good enough to overcome the natural flaws he brought to the table. One being his brain goes south for too long when he gets hurt. His reaction time isnt good enough. His judgement of distance also not good enough. Similar to khan their only fighting at the level they are because their attributes or attribute thats very strong is getting them by till its put to the test anyway where the rest of their natural attributes aren,t good enough to be elite.
     
  8. bbjc

    bbjc Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,726
    4,563
    Feb 25, 2012
    I am speaking in hindsight after watching the joshua v dubois fight in fairness. I had joshua down for paggering dubois pretty much the opposite of what ended up happening. I think its becoming clear tho joshua is just a bit too flawed against certain fighters anyway.
     
  9. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    They may have been in poor shape but the opposition they were in against was so low it shouldnt have made a difference

    ill need to rewatch the fight but Aj was looking good against Ruiz and was beating him handily and had him rocked and was going in for the kill when he got countered and hurt badly and it went down hill from there. Thats not really Mccrackens fault

    Taylor picked up a couple of very serious injuries after his stint with ben which im sure ruined him, with Ben he was still fresh

    I think you will find there are plenty of people who think ben is the second coming, and the worst thing is, ben himself believes he is also, you can tell with his smug persona and fake humbleness. This would be fine if he was actually doing something great but most of his fighters end up getting smashed up, so where he gets his ego from is so strange to me. Just as strange as the people who think hes a great trainer, they surely cant be basing it on in the ring performances of his fighters
     
  10. BaronSamedi

    BaronSamedi Active Member Full Member

    816
    1,020
    Mar 9, 2015
    Its not even about Aj, i agree Aj is highly flawed. Its about Ben davison and his overall coaching of all his fighters, Aj just happens to be the most recent victim of it with his worst ever performace
     
  11. bbjc

    bbjc Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,726
    4,563
    Feb 25, 2012
    The only person that thinks ben is the second coming is ben himself.

    The problem being tho....is peoples hate for him is clouding their judgement to the point hes being blamed for joshua.....who has shown time and time again hes flawed. Or fury being 24 stone fighting and beating wilder being seen as a negative on bens part or taylor being weight drained instead being down to injury after ben or leigh woods not being given credit for picking up the pieces after getting beat off jazza dickens.

    I think ben had aj fighting the way he always should have been fighting....with the type of flaws he had but it turned out it didnt really help aj much when it was put to the test. I m not a massive fan of ben tbh.....but he knows his stuff. Don charles would have been a better fit for aj....but like ben and every other trainer and human being we,re all flawed.

    He should have went with someone similar to charles after ruiz 1. But the truth is joshua doesnt really want to fight he wants to technically beat people without needing to fight and get hurt and be a real fighter. Thats what he was looking for looking back it was always going to end one way. He doesnt have the iq or the technical ability to do what he was trying to do. He probably saved himself some shellackings in training camps tho. Dubois was battle hardened on saturday night and joshua was not because imo joshua doesnt really want to commit to being battle hardened because it comes at a cost he probably doesnt need to pay.
     
  12. Cleaver

    Cleaver Member Full Member

    498
    492
    Sep 24, 2024
    There was legitimate doubt about the outcome going into Klitschko-Joshua, to be fair.
    Of course Klitschko was far from being a "live opponent" but there was a massive gulf in experience.
     
    Last edited: Sep 24, 2024
    Wizbit1013 and Beale like this.
  13. nurological

    nurological Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,453
    10,580
    May 25, 2012
    The point is McGuigan called live exactly what would happen if AJ listened to the advice.
     
    Wizbit1013, roeknott and Beale like this.
  14. Sonny1

    Sonny1 Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,509
    4,350
    Mar 11, 2013
    Yep. Terrible choice for Taylor who was a killer before teaming up with him.
     
    ash234 and Beale like this.
  15. Beale

    Beale Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,727
    9,814
    Feb 13, 2023
    Joshua was the big favourite with the bookmakers against a 41 year old man who had been inactive for 18 months due to the antics of Tyson Luke Fury.

    The only reason Hearn and Joshua took the fight was that the old man was finished yet he still nearly won.

    Hearn will have Joshua fighting a couple of 3rd tier boxers again such as Whyte or Pulev hoping a Charles Martin level fighter fights for or is awarded another vacant belt.
     
    Cleaver likes this.